Skip to Content

Choosing Between a Glock and a Revolver for New Gun Owners

When it comes to picking your first firearm, the decision can be overwhelming. Two of the most popular choices for beginners are semi-automatic handguns, like the Glock 19, and revolvers, such as a Smith & Wesson Model 686. Both options offer unique advantages, but which is the better fit for a new gun owner? Let’s break it down by comparing key features and considerations to help you make an informed decision.

Simplicity: The Revolver’s Strong Suit

Simplicity The Revolver’s Strong Suit
Image Credit: Survival World

For first-time gun owners, simplicity can be a deciding factor. Revolvers shine in this department with their straightforward operation. Open the cylinder, load your rounds, close it, and pull the trigger. Once you’ve emptied the cylinder, eject the spent casings, reload, and repeat. It’s a no-nonsense approach that makes revolvers extremely user-friendly.

On the other hand, semi-automatic handguns like the Glock require learning additional steps, such as chambering a round, managing magazines, and occasionally dealing with malfunctions. While not overly complicated, these extra steps can be intimidating for a beginner.

Reliability: Edge to the Revolver

Reliability Edge to the Revolver
Image Credit: Survival World

One of the most significant advantages of a revolver is its reliability. With high-quality ammunition, revolvers almost never fail to fire. There are no springs or feeding mechanisms to jam, making them a go-to option for those seeking absolute dependability.

That said, modern semi-automatics like the Glock 19 are also incredibly reliable. These pistols are designed to handle thousands of rounds without failure. While revolvers take the edge here, the gap is narrowing as semi-automatics continue to improve.

Trigger Control and Safety

Trigger Control and Safety
Image Credit: Survival World

The trigger pull on a revolver – especially in double-action mode – requires more effort and is longer than that of a semi-automatic handgun. This heavier trigger pull can act as a built-in safety feature, reducing the likelihood of accidental discharges. However, in single-action mode, the revolver’s trigger becomes much lighter and more sensitive, which could pose a risk in high-stress situations.

The Glock’s trigger pull is lighter and more consistent, making it easier to fire rapidly and accurately. However, this also means the user must be disciplined about keeping their finger off the trigger until ready to fire. For beginners, understanding and practicing proper trigger discipline is essential regardless of the firearm.

Round Capacity: Glock Takes the Lead

Round Capacity Glock Takes the Lead
Image Credit: Survival World

When it comes to capacity, semi-automatic pistols like the Glock have a clear advantage. With magazines that can hold 15 rounds or more, you’ll rarely find yourself out of ammo in critical situations. In contrast, most revolvers hold only five to six rounds, with some extended models offering up to seven.

While revolvers force you to reload more often, their simple design ensures this process is straightforward. On the flip side, swapping out a Glock magazine takes just seconds, keeping you ready for action.

Weight and Size: Balancing Trade-Offs

Weight and Size Balancing Trade Offs
Image Credit: Survival World

Revolvers, particularly those made of stainless steel, tend to be heavier than semi-automatic pistols. This added weight helps mitigate recoil, making revolvers comfortable to shoot, even with powerful cartridges like .357 Magnum. However, the heft can be a drawback for concealed carry, where lighter firearms are often preferred.

The Glock 19, built with a polymer frame, is significantly lighter while maintaining similar dimensions. Its smooth edges and compact size make it an excellent choice for concealed carry, giving it a slight edge in portability.

Customization Options

Customization Options
Image Credit: Survival World

Modern semi-automatic handguns like the Glock are designed with versatility in mind. Many models feature accessory rails for mounting lights or lasers and are compatible with red dot sights. These additions can enhance accuracy and usability, particularly in low-light conditions.

Revolvers, while timeless in design, lack these customization options. Their classic aesthetic appeals to purists, but they don’t offer the same adaptability as a semi-automatic handgun.

Ammunition Variety and Cost

Ammunition Variety and Cost
Image Credit: Survival World

Revolvers have the advantage of firing both .357 Magnum and .38 Special cartridges, providing flexibility for different situations. The .38 Special offers reduced recoil for training and casual shooting, while the .357 Magnum delivers powerful stopping power.

The Glock 19, chambered in 9mm, benefits from the widespread availability and affordability of its ammunition. This makes it a practical option for regular practice and personal defense.

Maintenance and Durability

Maintenance and Durability
Image Credit: Survival World

Revolvers are remarkably easy to maintain, thanks to their simple design and fewer moving parts. They’re less prone to dirt and debris interfering with their operation, making them ideal for those who may not clean their firearm as often.

Semi-automatic pistols require a bit more attention, with regular cleaning and lubrication needed to ensure consistent performance. However, modern models like the Glock are engineered for durability and can withstand significant wear and tear.

Concealed Carry Considerations

Concealed Carry Considerations
Image Credit: Survival World

For those interested in concealed carry, the Glock’s lightweight polymer frame and smooth contours make it an excellent choice. Its compact size fits easily under clothing without drawing attention.

Revolvers, while reliable, often have exposed hammers and bulkier designs that can snag on clothing. However, smaller revolvers specifically designed for concealed carry are available for those who prefer this platform.

Shooting Experience

Shooting Experience
Image Credit: Survival World

Many first-time shooters find revolvers more enjoyable to shoot due to their manageable recoil and satisfying mechanical action. The tactile experience of loading, firing, and ejecting rounds can make revolvers feel more intuitive and engaging.

Semi-automatic handguns, with their higher capacity and rapid-fire capabilities, are ideal for those looking to develop shooting skills over time. They offer a faster learning curve for advanced techniques and scenarios.

Longevity in Your Arsenal

Longevity in Your Arsenal
Image Credit: Survival World

Both revolvers and Glocks are investments that can serve you well for years. Many gun owners find themselves returning to revolvers for their timeless charm, even after transitioning to semi-automatics. Conversely, the Glock’s modern features and widespread popularity make it a staple in any firearm collection.

The Right Gun for You

The Right Gun for You
Image Credit: Survival World

Choosing between a Glock and a revolver as your first gun depends largely on your priorities. If simplicity, reliability, and a timeless shooting experience appeal to you, a revolver might be the way to go. On the other hand, if you value capacity, modern features, and versatility, a Glock – or a similar semi-automatic pistol – could be your perfect match.

Ultimately, the best firearm is the one you feel confident and comfortable using. Try out both options if you can, and let your personal preferences guide your decision. After all, the goal is to choose a firearm that fits your needs and helps you embark on a safe, enjoyable shooting journey.

Your Experiences

Your Experiences
Image Credit: Survival World

What factors are most important to you when choosing your first firearm: simplicity, capacity, reliability, or customization? Why? How do you plan to use your firearm – home defense, concealed carry, or recreational shooting – and how does that influence your choice between a Glock and a revolver? For those with firearm experience, what was your first gun, and would you recommend it to someone else starting out? Why or why not?