Skip to Content

State-Level Gun Bans Could Be Over If This Bill Passes

A new piece of legislation has the potential to reshape the landscape of gun laws across the United States. Known as the Second Amendment Guarantee Act (SAGA), this bill, introduced by Congresswoman Claudia Tenney (NY-24), aims to prohibit states from enforcing bans on firearms that are otherwise legal under federal law. If passed, the bill would directly challenge state-level restrictions like New York’s controversial SAFE Act, reigniting debates about the balance between state and federal authority on gun regulation.

What the SAGA Act Proposes

What the SAGA Act Proposes
Image Credit: Survival World

The SAGA Act, introduced on January 15, 2025, seeks to nullify state-level bans on the sale, manufacturing, possession, or importation of any rifle or shotgun that complies with federal law. According to Tenney’s official press release, the bill is specifically designed to overturn laws like New York’s SAFE Act, which she described as unconstitutional. Additional sponsors of the legislation include Representatives Doug LaMalfa (CA-1) and Nick Langworthy (NY-23), underscoring Republican support for the bill.

Tenney’s motivation for introducing the bill stems from her opposition to laws she claims infringe on Second Amendment rights. “The Constitution clearly established our Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms,” she stated. “This legislation upholds our country’s founding principle of protecting the rights of law-abiding Americans, even from liberal states with anti-gun policies.”

Criticism of New York’s SAFE Act

Criticism of New York's SAFE Act
Image Credit: Survival World

New York’s SAFE Act (Secure Ammunition and Firearms Enforcement Act), signed into law in 2013 under former Governor Andrew Cuomo, is one of the key targets of the SAGA Act. The SAFE Act implemented measures such as universal background checks, increased penalties for gun-related crimes, and a lifetime prison sentence for murdering first responders. Critics like Tenney argue that the act unlawfully restricts the rights of New Yorkers by banning certain firearms outright.

A Direct Violation of 2A

A Direct Violation of 2A
Image Credit: Survival World

According to George Gandy’s reporting for Rochester First, Tenney has repeatedly called the SAFE Act unconstitutional, viewing it as a direct violation of the Second Amendment. Gandy also highlighted how local leaders in Rochester, such as Mayor Malik Evans, remain focused on addressing gun violence by extending emergency measures and supporting state-level firearm restrictions. This stark contrast highlights the ideological divide between advocates for gun rights and those emphasizing gun control as a means to reduce violence.

The National Scope of SAGA

The National Scope of SAGA
Image Credit: Guns & Gadgets 2nd Amendment News

Although the SAGA Act was introduced with New York in mind, its implications would extend nationwide. Jared Yanis, host of Guns & Gadgets, emphasized in his video coverage that the bill would challenge all state-level firearm bans, such as assault weapon prohibitions and state-specific gun rosters. Yanis described the bill as “phenomenal” and a necessary step to protect constitutional rights.

Yanis also pointed out that while the bill’s goals align with other pro-gun legislation—such as efforts to abolish the National Firearms Act (NFA) or implement concealed carry reciprocity—it faces significant hurdles in Congress. He noted that passing any Republican-led initiative would require 60 votes in the Senate, a difficult feat given the current political climate.

The Debate Over States’ Rights

The Debate Over States' Rights
Image Credit: Liberty Doll

In her video, Liberty Doll, another prominent gun rights advocate, explored the tension between federal oversight and states’ rights. While she generally supports states managing their own affairs, she argued that state governments lose their legitimacy when they infringe upon fundamental rights, such as those protected by the Second Amendment. Liberty Doll acknowledged the bill’s slim chances of passing but praised it as an important opportunity to push back against what she sees as overreach by anti-gun states.

Liberty Doll also pointed out that many state-level bans are already being challenged in court, particularly in light of recent Supreme Court decisions like District of Columbia v. Heller and New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. She suggested that even if the SAGA Act fails to pass, its introduction could influence broader legal and cultural battles over gun rights.

Political Hurdles Ahead

Political Hurdles Ahead
Image Credit: Survival World

Despite its bold goals, the SAGA Act faces an uphill battle in Congress. Liberty Doll and Jared Yanis both highlighted the challenges of securing bipartisan support for gun rights legislation. The current Republican majority in the House may not be enough to ensure the bill’s passage, especially in the Senate, where Democrats hold significant influence. Yanis noted that reconciliation procedures could potentially offer a pathway, but even that remains uncertain.

This political reality underscores the broader struggle between federal gun rights advocates and state governments, particularly in regions with stricter firearm laws. Tenney’s bill is a clear response to what she and her allies see as an overstep by states like New York, California, and others that have implemented rigorous gun control measures.

Why the SAGA Act Stands Out

Why the SAGA Act Stands Out
Image Credit: Survival World

What makes the SAGA Act particularly fascinating is its sweeping approach. Unlike many gun rights initiatives that focus on specific policies, this bill directly challenges the principle of state autonomy in regulating firearms. If successful, it could set a precedent for federal intervention in other areas where state laws conflict with constitutional rights. This raises questions about the balance of power between states and the federal government – a debate that goes beyond the gun rights issue.

A Broader Second Amendment Strategy

A Broader Second Amendment Strategy
Image Credit: Survival World

Congresswoman Tenney’s push for the SAGA Act is part of a larger effort to expand gun rights at the federal level. According to Liberty Doll, Tenney is also a supporter of the Concealed Carry Reciprocity Act, the No Registry Act, and other initiatives aimed at reducing federal and state-level restrictions on firearms. These efforts are consistent with a broader Republican strategy to roll back gun control measures, particularly in light of recent court rulings that have favored Second Amendment advocates.

Public Reactions

Public Reactions
Image Credit: Survival World

The SAGA Act has sparked strong reactions from both sides of the debate. Gun rights advocates have celebrated the bill as a necessary defense of constitutional freedoms. Meanwhile, gun control proponents argue that measures like the SAFE Act are essential for public safety, particularly in urban areas plagued by gun violence.

Mayor Evans’ decision to extend Rochester’s gun violence state of emergency underscores the urgency of this issue for many local leaders. Efforts to restrict access to firearms for domestic violence offenders, as proposed by New York Governor Kathy Hochul, represent another approach to addressing the crisis. This juxtaposition highlights the complexity of balancing individual rights with community safety.

The Bigger Picture

The Bigger Picture
Image Credit: Survival World

What’s striking about the SAGA Act is how it reframes the gun debate in the United States. By focusing on federal law as the ultimate standard, the bill challenges the patchwork nature of state regulations. This raises important questions about fairness and consistency. Why should a firearm be legal in one state but banned in another? For many gun rights advocates, this inconsistency undermines the principle of equal protection under the law.

At the same time, the bill’s potential to override state autonomy is a double-edged sword. While it could protect individual rights in states with strict gun laws, it also sets a precedent for federal overreach in other areas. This is a debate worth watching, as it could have far-reaching implications beyond the Second Amendment.

A Moment of Reckoning

A Moment of Reckoning
Image Credit: Survival World

The SAGA Act represents more than just a legislative proposal; it’s a flashpoint in the ongoing battle over gun rights in America. Whether or not it passes, its introduction has already reignited discussions about the limits of state power, the role of federal government, and the meaning of the Second Amendment. As debates unfold, one thing is clear: the fight over guns in the United States is far from over.

The Effect of State-level Gun Bans

The Effect of State level Gun Bans
Image Credit: Survival World

What are your thoughts? Should the federal government have the authority to override state-level laws on issues like gun control, or does this undermine the principle of states’ rights? Do state-level gun bans actually reduce gun violence, or do they disproportionately impact law-abiding citizens without addressing the root causes of crime? If the SAGA Act were to pass, how might it affect the current judicial battles over state-level firearm restrictions? Could it reshape the legal landscape entirely?