A simple holiday photo has set off a global debate about speech, guns, and government power.
In a report for The Telegraph, crime correspondent Will Bolton describes how British IT consultant Jon Richelieu-Booth was arrested in the UK after posting a picture of himself holding a shotgun in Florida on LinkedIn.
That story then reached Elon Musk, who shared it with more than 200 million followers and added one short line that lit up the gun-rights world:
“And this is why we have the first and second amendments in America.”
A Holiday Photo That Turned Into A Criminal Case
According to Will Bolton, Jon Richelieu-Booth is a 50-year-old IT consultant who traveled to Florida and visited a private homestead with friends.
On Aug. 13, he posted a LinkedIn update with a photo of himself holding a shotgun, attached to a longer message about his day and work activities.
He told Bolton that there was nothing threatening in the text.
Richelieu-Booth says West Yorkshire Police later showed up at his home.
He recalls an officer warning him to “be careful” what he posted online and to think about “how it makes people feel.”
Bolton reports that Richelieu-Booth offered to prove the photo was taken in the United States, where he had been legally handling the gun.
Officers told him that wasn’t necessary.
“Thirteen Weeks Of Hell” In Modern Britain
Will Bolton writes that things escalated sharply on Aug. 24, when two officers returned to Richelieu-Booth’s home shortly after 10 p.m. and arrested him.
A bail document seen by The Telegraph, Bolton says, referred to allegations of possessing a firearm with intent to cause fear of violence, and a stalking allegation tied to a house photograph on social media.
Richelieu-Booth was held overnight in a cell and then interviewed.
Bolton reports that he was released on bail until late October, but police then came to his property three more times.
He was re-arrested in October for allegedly breaching bail conditions, although that charge was later dropped.
The firearms and stalking allegations were also dropped, Bolton notes, but prosecutors then charged him with a public order offense related to a different social media post.
He was told to appear at Bradford magistrates’ court on Nov. 25 for allegedly displaying a “writing/sign/visible representation with intent to cause harassment/alarm or distress.”
According to Richelieu-Booth, that charge, too, was eventually dropped.
In Bolton’s reporting, Richelieu-Booth says he does not even know which post that public order charge was based on.
He also claims he doesn’t remember being questioned about a specific post on that date.
The Cost Of An Investigation That Went Nowhere
Will Bolton reports that West Yorkshire Police seized Richelieu-Booth’s phone and computers.
As a self-employed IT contractor, he says that has effectively stopped him from working.
He describes the experience as “massive overreach.”
Bolton quotes him asking when Britain went from disagreeing with opinions to “calling the police” instead.
Richelieu-Booth tells The Telegraph that he used to support the police and believed in their role, but says now, “I have no faith in the police.”
He also tells Bolton he plans to file a case against West Yorkshire Police, saying he has been put through “13 weeks of hell” and will seek “quite a lot of damages.”
A spokesman for West Yorkshire Police, in a statement to Bolton, says officers received a stalking complaint involving “serious alarm or distress,” partly tied to social media posts with pictures of a man posing with firearms that the complainant took as a threat.
The spokesman says police investigated and charged a man with a public order offense, but the case was discontinued by the Crown Prosecution Service.
Musk Weighs In: “This Is Why We Have The First And Second Amendments”
That alone would have been a controversial UK story.
But it jumped across the Atlantic when Elon Musk reacted to it on X.
In a short post, Musk wrote, “And this is why we have the first and second amendments in America,” directly tying Richelieu-Booth’s ordeal to U.S. protections for speech and gun rights.
That single sentence turned a British policing dispute into a viral pro-Second Amendment moment.
Attorney Mark W. Smith, on his YouTube channel The Four Boxes Diner, tells viewers that Musk sent that message out to roughly 229 million followers on X.
Smith calls it a “critical statement” in support of the right to keep and bear arms and says Musk is again stepping up in the fight over the Second Amendment.
Smith reminds his audience that during the 2024 election cycle, Musk campaigned for Donald Trump in key battleground states and cast himself as a defender of both free speech and gun rights.
Mark W. Smith Connects The Dots To History
In his video, Mark W. Smith walks through the core facts of the case as reported in the UK: a British IT consultant, a Florida shotgun photo, a LinkedIn post, and then an arrest back home by West Yorkshire Police.
Smith notes that the photo showed what he describes as a basic shotgun on a Florida homestead, nothing exotic or alarming in his view.
He stresses that Richelieu-Booth was in the U.S. legally and legally handling the firearm when the picture was taken.
Smith says he is “embarrassed” by what he calls the behavior of the British government and jokes that Winston Churchill would be rolling in his grave.
Then he goes much deeper.
Mark W. Smith uses the case as a launchpad to explain how, in his telling, Britain once had gun rights similar to the United States until the Firearms Act of 1920.
He cites the historical work of Professor Stephen Halbrook, highlighting the “Blackwell Report” after World War I, which warned about large numbers of armed, trained men returning home.
Smith says the British government feared revolution more than crime and responded by tightening gun laws and giving police broad discretion over who could own firearms.
For Smith, the lesson is that once a government decides it fears its own people, it moves to disarm them – and over time, other freedoms erode as well.
He argues that Musk’s post is really about that connection: the First and Second Amendments rise and fall together.
Colion Noir Sees A Warning For America
Gun rights commentator Colion Noir reaches similar conclusions in his own video, calling Richelieu-Booth’s case one of the “most terrifying examples of government overreach” he has seen in a long time.
Noir tells his viewers that Richelieu-Booth did something “legal, harmless, normal” in America – shooting guns and posting a photo – and then came home to a country where a picture could trigger an arrest.
He emphasizes that this ordeal was not a one-day misunderstanding.
Noir walks through the same 13-week timeline described by Will Bolton: the warning visit, the late-night arrest, dropped charges, then another arrest, and ongoing harassment.
He focuses on the police warning about the “impact on others’ feelings,” arguing that this shows how far things can go when subjective offense becomes a basis for law enforcement.
Noir quotes Richelieu-Booth’s line about being put through “13 weeks of hell” and calling the police response “massive overreach,” and says even that phrase may be too soft.
He argues that this is what happens when citizens are disarmed and “the state can do whatever it wants whenever it wants with zero fear of the population pushing back.”
Why This Story Hit A Nerve In The U.S.
It’s not hard to see why Musk’s short message took off in American gun circles.
Will Bolton’s reporting gives the case a detailed, human core: a single LinkedIn photo, a man who says he can’t work because police took his devices, and a legal process that kept spinning even as charges were dropped.
Mark W. Smith then plugs that into a century-long timeline of British gun control, showing how one law in 1920 helped change the balance between citizens and the state.
Colion Noir pushes the argument forward, treating the whole incident as a preview of what could happen in the U.S. if the Second Amendment is weakened or dismissed as outdated.
What makes the story particularly striking is how ordinary the original act was.
Plenty of Americans have vacation photos at a range or a farm holding a shotgun.
To them, the idea that such a picture could later be treated as part of a stalking complaint, as Bolton reports the West Yorkshire Police spokesman describing, feels almost unreal.
At the same time, the UK spokesman’s statement to Bolton shows the other side: a complainant who said they felt seriously alarmed and believed the firearm photos were a threat.
Those two realities – one person seeing a normal tourist moment, another seeing a warning – collided inside a legal system that has far fewer protections for speech and gun ownership than the U.S. Constitution provides.
A Viral Reminder Of What’s At Stake
When Elon Musk wrote, “And this is why we have the first and second amendments in America,” he tapped straight into that tension.
Will Bolton’s article laid the groundwork.
Mark W. Smith turned it into a lesson about history and power.
Colion Noir turned it into a warning about America’s future.
Musk’s massive audience did the rest.
You don’t have to agree with every argument from Smith or Noir to see why so many people found this story unsettling.
If a single, legal vacation photo can grow into “13 weeks of hell,” as Richelieu-Booth told Bolton, then the line between safety and overreach starts to look very thin.
That’s exactly the line Musk was pointing at – and why his latest pro-2A message, born from a bizarre overseas case, has spread so fast across the American debate.
UP NEXT: “Heavily Armed” — See Which States Are The Most Strapped
Image Credit: Survival World
Americans have long debated the role of firearms, but one thing is sure — some states are far more armed than others. See where your state ranks in this new report on firearm ownership across the U.S.
The article Musk’s new pro-2A message goes viral after bizarre case overseas first appeared on Survival World.
A former park ranger and wildlife conservationist, Lisa’s passion for survival started with her deep connection to nature. Raised on a small farm in northern Wisconsin, she learned how to grow her own food, raise livestock, and live off the land. Lisa is our dedicated Second Amendment news writer and also focuses on homesteading, natural remedies, and survival strategies. Lisa aims to help others live more sustainably and prepare for the unexpected.
