Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Second Amendment

Majority of States Finally Take a Stand Against What They Call Federal Overreach

Majority of States Finally Take a Stand Against What They Call Federal Overreach
Image Credit: Austin Knudsen for Montana

In a powerful act of legal defiance, 28 U.S. states have formed a united front against what they describe as unconstitutional gun control. On June 5, 2025, Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen filed an amicus brief with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, challenging Maine’s 72-hour firearm waiting period law. The brief was supported by attorneys general and legislative leaders from over half the country. As reported by the Montana Department of Justice, the coalition argues that the law directly violates the Second Amendment and fails the historical test set by the U.S. Supreme Court.

This is no fringe uprising. This is a coordinated pushback from a majority of the states, signaling that the tension between federal court rulings and aggressive state-level gun laws is reaching a boiling point.

The Law in Question: Maine’s 72-Hour Delay

The Law in Question Maine’s 72 Hour Delay
Image Credit: Survival World

The law at the center of the case, Beckwith v. Frey, requires gun buyers in Maine to wait 72 hours after purchase – even if they’ve already passed a background check. According to Guns & Gadgets host Jared Yanis, this means that even a law-abiding citizen who has cleared all legal requirements can’t take their firearm home until three days later.

Maine claims the law helps prevent impulsive violence like suicides and homicides. But critics say there’s no historical evidence to support that such delays were ever part of America’s legal tradition. And under the Supreme Court’s Bruen decision, gun laws must be deeply rooted in history to survive.

Montana’s Argument: Bruen Leaves No Room for Delay

Montana's Argument Bruen Leaves No Room for Delay
Image Credit: Survival World

As the Montana DOJ press release explains, the coalition’s legal argument hinges on the 2022 New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen decision. That ruling requires courts to uphold only those gun laws that are consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. Attorney General Knudsen argues Maine failed that test. “Maine failed to carry its burden,” he wrote, “to show that its waiting-period law is part of the historical tradition that delineates the outer bounds of the right to keep and bear arms.”

Knudsen goes further, stating that Maine’s comparisons to old licensing and intoxication laws are flawed. Those laws applied only to specific individuals, like the intoxicated, not all gun buyers. Maine’s law, by contrast, treats every person as potentially dangerous, without exception.

Jared Yanis Says This Is a National Turning Point

Jared Yanis Says This Is a National Turning Point
Image Credit: Guns & Gadgets 2nd Amendment News

In his Guns & Gadgets video, Jared Yanis called the coalition’s move “massive.” He said, “This isn’t a fringe moment – this is big.” He pointed out that the First Circuit Court of Appeals had already refused to grant Maine a stay, allowing the district court’s injunction to stand. That alone, he noted, is rare. Courts don’t often block state gun laws so early in a case. And yet, they did.

Yanis warns that if Maine’s waiting period stands, other states like California or Illinois could follow with even longer delays – seven, 14, maybe 30 days. “What’s to stop them?” he asked. “Waiting periods don’t stop criminals. They only punish law-abiding citizens.”

Who Joined the Brief?

Who Joined the Brief
Image Credit: Survival World

The list of states backing this brief reads like a red state roll call. According to the Montana DOJ, it includes Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia, and Wyoming. The Arizona Legislature also signed on, represented by both the Senate President and the Speaker of the House.

Larry Keane, Senior Vice President and General Counsel at the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF), praised the action on social media. “Attorney General Knudsen leads 28-state coalition against unconstitutional waiting-period law,” he posted on X.

Maine’s Defense: A “More Nuanced” Approach?

Maine’s Defense A “More Nuanced” Approach
Image Credit: Survival World

Maine is not backing down easily. The state argues that modern problems, such as impulsive violence and rapid-fire technology, justify a more “nuanced” interpretation of the Second Amendment. But the Montana-led coalition firmly rejects that view. According to the amicus brief, impulsivity is not a new human trait. And despite modern gun tech, Maine hasn’t shown any “rapid advancements” that would demand a different legal framework.

The court in Bruen was clear: modern gun laws must be rooted in longstanding historical tradition. New social problems don’t allow governments to bypass the Constitution.

The Bruen Test: Historical Evidence or Bust

The Bruen Test Historical Evidence or Bust
Image Credit: Survival World

The coalition’s brief methodically tears apart Maine’s historical arguments. As summarized by Guns & Gadgets, here are the key points:

  1. Acquisition is protected – The Second Amendment protects the right to acquire firearms, not just possess them.
  2. No historical waiting laws – Maine failed to present any waiting-period laws from the Founding or Reconstruction eras.
  3. Bad analogies – Maine’s use of licensing or intoxication laws doesn’t apply because those had clear exceptions.
  4. Impulse control isn’t new – Humans have always acted impulsively; that’s no reason to delay rights.
  5. No standard at all – Maine’s law applies blindly to everyone, without individualized review or process.

A Real-Life Problem With Real Consequences

A Real Life Problem With Real Consequences
Image Credit: Survival World

Let’s put this in real-world terms. Imagine a woman in Maine who fears for her safety. She passes a background check and wants a firearm for immediate self-defense. Under this law, she can’t get it until 72 hours later. If something happens in that time, what then? This isn’t just theoretical – it’s about whether the government can block access to a life-saving tool based on assumptions and no historical precedent.

As Yanis explained in his video, “They have stopped me from protecting myself. They have infringed upon my Second Amendment.”

A Case of Presumed Guilt?

A Case of Presumed Guilt
Image Credit: Survival World

One of the most striking criticisms of the Maine law is that it assumes everyone is a threat until proven otherwise. Attorney General Knudsen hammered this point home in the press release: “The waiting-period law employs no standard at all to justify disarming individuals.” In essence, it flips the presumption of innocence on its head.

This approach not only flies in the face of constitutional protections, it undermines trust in the legal system. People expect laws to treat them fairly, especially when they’ve followed all the rules.

Could This Spread?

Could This Spread
Image Credit: Survival World

That’s the concern shared by gun rights advocates across the country. If Maine’s law survives court scrutiny, it opens the door for other states to create even stricter waiting periods, regardless of whether the buyer poses any threat. “If Maine gets away with this,” Yanis warned, “your state could be next.”

This is why the 28-state brief is so significant. It’s not just about one law. It’s about setting the tone for how Second Amendment rights are treated nationwide in the aftermath of Bruen.

A Warning Shot to Washington

A Warning Shot to Washington
Image Credit: Survival World

From my perspective, this moment is more than legal wrangling – it’s a warning shot to federal and state governments that the people aren’t backing down. The fact that 28 states rallied together shows just how serious this debate has become. And it highlights a growing divide: one side argues for historical consistency, the other for modern flexibility.

But history matters. When the Supreme Court says the Constitution means what it did in 1791, that has to mean something. Otherwise, we risk letting fear and bureaucracy rewrite our rights.

What’s Next for Beckwith v. Frey?

What’s Next for Beckwith v. Frey
Image Credit: Survival World

The First Circuit is now reviewing the case. If it sides with the lower court, Maine’s law will remain blocked. If not, the waiting period goes back into effect, and more states may follow suit with similar laws. That’s why this legal fight is so important.

In the meantime, Second Amendment supporters are being urged to stay involved. As Jared Yanis put it: “Call your state attorney general. Ask them why they didn’t sign on. Stay informed and stay mobilized.”

You May Also Like

News

Image Credit: Max Velocity - Severe Weather Center