Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Second Amendment

How Decades of Gun Control Created a Legal Trap – And One Judge Called It Out with Nationwide Implications

How Decades of Gun Control Created a Legal Trap And One Judge Called It Out
Image Credit: Survival World

In a surprising decision that’s now under appeal, a federal district judge ruled that the ban on civilian-owned machine guns may actually violate the Second Amendment. The case, United States v. Morgan, comes out of Kansas and challenges the 1986 Hughes Amendment – a law that bans civilians from owning newly manufactured machine guns. Attorney and YouTuber Tom Grieve broke down the case in a recent video, calling it “potentially the most important gun case in decades.”

According to Grieve, this is the first time in a long while that a federal trial court has directly stated that machine guns – yes, actual automatic weapons – are protected “arms” under the Second Amendment. If that ruling stands, it could unravel a huge part of federal gun control as we know it.

The Case: Glock Switches and AR-15 Conversions

The Case Glock Switches and AR 15 Conversions
Image Credit: Tom Grieve

The case involves a man named Morgan who was charged with illegal possession of a machine gun under 18 U.S.C. § 922(o). This section of the law, part of the Hughes Amendment, bans any civilian from possessing machine guns made after 1986. The guns in question included a modified AR-15 and a Glock pistol converted with an illegal auto switch.

Grieve explained that the district judge tossed two of the charges, arguing that machine guns qualify as “bearable arms” and thus fall within the protections of the Second Amendment. “This is a big moment,” Grieve said. “This judge didn’t just side with the Second Amendment. He laid out a clear constitutional road map.”

Why the Judge Said Machine Guns Are Protected

Why the Judge Said Machine Guns Are Protected
Image Credit: Survival World

The judge relied heavily on the text of the Second Amendment and key rulings like District of Columbia v. Heller (2008) and New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022). According to the court, because machine guns are “bearable arms” and there’s no historical tradition of banning them in the founding era, the law banning them fails the Bruen test.

As Grieve explained, the judge emphasized that militias during the Revolutionary era reported to duty with the most advanced weapons they had – and today, that equivalent includes machine guns. “Well-regulated,” Grieve reminds viewers, didn’t mean government restrictions. It meant “well-equipped and well-trained.”

Heller and Bruen: The Supreme Court’s Foundation

Heller and Bruen The Supreme Court’s Foundation
Image Credit: Survival World

Grieve took time to revisit the Heller and Bruen decisions because they now set the standard for all Second Amendment cases. In Heller, the Court ruled that the Second Amendment protects an individual’s right to own firearms in common use. Bruen went further, requiring any modern gun law to be rooted in a historic tradition of regulation.

The judge in Morgan used both decisions to question the constitutionality of the machine gun ban. If militias used the best weapons available at the time of the Founding, and machine guns are today’s equivalent, the court argued, they should be protected.

Grieve Slams the Government’s “Circular Reasoning”

Grieve Slams the Government’s “Circular Reasoning”
Image Credit: Survival World

One of Grieve’s most powerful critiques came when he addressed what he called “the government’s carousel logic.” The government argues that machine guns aren’t in common use, so they aren’t protected. But they’re not in common use because the government banned them 40 years ago.

“That’s circular reasoning,” Grieve said. “It’s like if we taxed electric cars at 90%, then banned them, and then argued they weren’t popular enough to be protected. It’s nonsense.” He stressed that scarcity created by regulation shouldn’t be used to justify more regulation. It’s a self-fulfilling trap – and one he says threatens any future gun type not yet in “common use.”

A Manufactured Rarity

A Manufactured Rarity
Image Credit: Survival World

Grieve went deeper into the idea that the machine gun ban was never about safety – it was about making ownership financially and legally impossible. Under the National Firearms Act of 1934, owners had to pay a $200 tax to register a machine gun, which would be over $4,000 in today’s money. Then in 1986, the Hughes Amendment outright banned new machine guns for civilians.

Today, only about 170,000 legally registered machine guns exist, and the number drops each year. “Of course they’re not in common use,” Grieve argued. “The government made sure of that.”

The Dangerous and Unusual Clause – Debunked

The Dangerous and Unusual Clause Debunked
Image Credit: Survival World

A common justification for banning machine guns is the idea that they’re “dangerous and unusual.” But as Grieve pointed out, all firearms are dangerous – that’s what makes them useful. The real legal question is whether they’re unusual.

In the 2016 case Caetano v. Massachusetts, Justices Alito and Thomas wrote that a weapon cannot be banned if it is “commonly used for lawful purposes.” Grieve emphasized this distinction, saying, “Dangerousness doesn’t matter when we’re talking about a whole class of arms. Machine guns, in design and function, are not unusual to military and militia purposes.”

This Case Exposes the Game

This Case Exposes the Game
Image Credit: Survival World

What struck me most about this case is how it reveals a quiet legal trick that’s been running for decades. Ban a weapon. Make it hard to get. Then wait a few decades and say, “Nobody uses it – must not be important.” That’s not just bad logic. It’s manipulation. And the worst part? It works – until someone like this judge calls it out.

Whether or not this ruling survives appeal, it has finally put the spotlight on how the government uses regulation to shape the narrative. Machine guns didn’t fall out of favor naturally – they were regulated into rarity.

Will the Supreme Court Take This Up?

Will the Supreme Court Take This Up
Image Credit: Survival World

Grieve is cautiously skeptical about whether the Supreme Court will take the case. While he believes the Constitution clearly protects machine guns under the logic of Heller and Bruen, he’s not holding his breath. “The Court has already declined over 100 Second Amendment petitions in the last few years,” he said. “They’ve done good work, but they haven’t gone as far as they could.”

Still, Grieve believes a machine gun test is coming – it’s just a matter of when. If Morgan makes it to the top, it could force the Supreme Court to finally decide whether machine guns fall within the Second Amendment’s protection.

Why the Militia Argument Matters

Why the Militia Argument Matters
Image Credit: Survival World

One of Grieve’s strongest points was about the core reason the Second Amendment exists: to ensure a militia capable of resisting tyranny or responding to threats. Militias didn’t show up with kitchen knives – they brought their best weapons. In today’s context, machine guns are that modern equivalent. “The right to bear arms means the right to bear effective arms,” Grieve said.

This idea isn’t new. Even in Heller, the Court recognized that weapons used by citizens in militia service were central to the Second Amendment’s intent. That’s why the judge in Morgan framed machine guns as “essential” to a well-regulated militia, not as fringe or exotic tools.

A Rare Win in a Tough Fight

A Rare Win in a Tough Fight
Image Credit: Survival World

At the end of his video, Grieve closed with a quote from George Washington: “A free people ought not only be armed, but disciplined.” That’s the heart of this case. It’s not just about one man with a Glock switch – it’s about whether the Constitution still means what it says.

Right now, Morgan is a rare moment of clarity in a legal field full of contradiction. Whether it gets overturned or becomes the foundation of a new precedent, one thing is clear: it has exposed a legal trap decades in the making. And for once, someone in a black robe had the courage to say so.

You May Also Like

News

Image Credit: Max Velocity - Severe Weather Center