The ATF says it’s streamlining Form 1, the application Americans use to make and register NFA firearms.
Jared Yanis at Guns & Gadgets broke down the agency’s 30-day notice, explaining that the revision removes CLEO notifications, enables digital signatures, and supports electronic fingerprints and phone-captured photos.
He also noted the changes reflect the coming tax repeal for most NFA items under what he called the “Big Beautiful Bill,” with a full move to an all-electronic NFA system targeted for 2026.
Curtis Hallstrom at The VSO Gun Channel welcomed some of the cleanup. But he cautioned that calling this a “massive overhaul” oversells it. In his view, a lot of what ATF is publicizing was already happening in practice with eForms.
Both creators agree on one point. The process may get smoother, but the NFA regime remains a constitutional mess in their eyes.
What ATF Says Is Changing
Yanis walked through the official notice and pulled out the operational stuff gun owners actually feel.
He said ATF reports Form 1 volume jumped from ~25,000 per year to almost 149,000, which is a huge surge. The agency also claims the average time to complete an application fell from about 30 minutes to roughly 12, thanks to eForms and other modernizations.
More importantly, Yanis highlighted practical wins. No more CLEO notification requirement. Digital and electronic signatures allowed.
Electronic fingerprints supported. Cell-phone selfies or scanned photo IDs accepted for identity. Duplicated form pages will auto-populate to cut errors and redundancy. And the photo box itself goes away because you can attach your ID or a passport photo.
He added that references to pay.gov and the eForms portal are now baked into the document. There are also instructions for married couples filing jointly, cleaned-up language, contact emails for ATF offices, and notes about refunds.
That’s the nuts and bolts. Less paper. Fewer hoops. More online.
The Tax Twist Everyone’s Watching
Yanis pointed to the most sensitive topic in the announcement: money.
He explained the revised instructions explicitly distinguish what still gets a $200 tax and what does not. According to his summary, the paid tax remains for machine guns and destructive devices.
But for other categories like short-barreled rifles and suppressors, the update reflects a “$0” tax under the new law schedule beginning January 1, 2026.
He stressed his position that none of this makes NFA regulation legitimate. He believes the entire scheme is unconstitutional. But if you’re going to use the process, his bottom line is simple: the government is about to make it easier and cheaper to navigate.
Curtis landed in a similar place. He said the tax-line clarifications are real and necessary because the form had to be updated anyway to reflect that change.
He just doesn’t think ATF deserves victory laps for features people already had.
Is It Really a “Major Overhaul”?
Hallstrom’s skepticism is practical, not theatrical.
He’s filed multiple Form 1s and Form 4s. From his experience, eForms already let you upload digital fingerprints, attach photos, and auto-fill redundant fields. He said many CLEO offices were already treating the old notification copies like dead paper.
In some jurisdictions, those notices were literally getting trashed or ignored because departments didn’t want the extra paperwork burden.
So when he hears “overhaul,” he hears marketing. Yes, he called the formal deletion of the CLEO copy requirement a good thing.
Yes, he thinks clarifying the $0 tax for most items matters. But for him, most of the process-flow sugar was already baked into the cake.
That critique is worth sitting with. Government sometimes re-announces what it already does, just in friendlier packaging. It doesn’t mean there’s nothing new. It does mean gun owners should separate true change from rebranding.
The Push Toward a Fully Digital NFA
Yanis said ATF wants Form 1, and the wider NFA ecosystem, fully electronic by the end of 2026.
That has obvious upsides. No stacks of duplicate pages. Fewer mail delays. Fewer clerical errors. Faster identity verification. Clearer receipts and status checks. If you’ve fought with scanners and wet signatures, this is a relief.
It also has a tradeoff. A centralized digital system is very, very searchable. What makes bureaucracy faster can make surveillance simpler.
Yanis flagged that concern directly. He warned that digitization gives the government “more info… in their centralized control,” which is exactly what many gun owners don’t want from a registry-driven regime.
That tension isn’t going away. Efficiency and centralization travel together. The question is whether the gains at the front counter are worth the risks in the database.
What This Means If You’re Filing
For a first-timer or an occasional maker, the path looks clearer.
Under the changes Yanis described, you’ll prepare a digital packet, use eForms, attach an ID or passport photo, and submit electronic fingerprints.
You won’t mail a CLEO copy. You’ll sign electronically. The form will duplicate and auto-fill where needed. And if you are building an SBR or buying a suppressor after the new tax schedule kicks in, that $200 hit goes away.
Curtis’s advice is to temper expectations. If you’ve been using eForms, much of this will feel familiar. What may feel different is the lack of any CLEO detour and the clean tax line on the document itself.
Both ways, the friction is lower. The gates are still there.
Helpful Streamlining, Same Old Core Problem
I think Yanis is right to call out the practical wins. The CLEO copy was a zombie requirement that confused applicants and tempted locals into shadow lists.
Killing it matters. Digital signatures and electronic fingerprints reduce trips, costs, and failure points. Clear tax lines reduce surprises.
I also think Hallstrom is right about the hype. A big chunk of this “overhaul” is just ATF catching the form up to the workflow many people already used. That doesn’t make it meaningless. It just means we shouldn’t pretend it’s revolutionary.
Zoom out and the core tension remains. The smoother the process, the easier it is to participate in a registry architecture that many gun owners oppose in principle. Making the turnstile spin faster doesn’t change that it’s still a turnstile.
If the NFA is unconstitutional – as both creators argue – then a cleaner form is lipstick on a very old pig. If you’re stuck dealing with it, though, you’d rather it be fast, clear, and less invasive. Both can be true at the same time.
One More Practical Note
Yanis emphasized that ATF posted this under a 30-day notice period for public comment before the Office of Management and Budget signs off. If you care about the details, that’s the window to speak up.
He also noted a rare move: ATF acknowledged a joint comment from an NFA dealer endorsing the CLEO removal and digital signatures, and responded by reaffirming the 2026 all-electronic goal.
Agencies don’t always engage like that. It’s a small sign that constructive feedback can shape the margins.
Curtis’s reminder stands, though. Expect spin. Expect press releases that frame routine cleanups as breakthroughs. Check the document language, not the headlines.
From Jared Yanis’s walkthrough, Form 1 is getting simpler on its face. No CLEO notification. Digital signatures and e-fingerprints. Selfie or ID uploads. Fewer redundant fields. Clear tax lines that reflect a $0 tax for most NFA items starting January 1, 2026. And a push to a fully digital NFA by the end of next year.
From Curtis Hallstrom’s seat, most of this is incremental and overdue, not a revolution. The best part is formalizing what already worked and stripping away a pointless local copy.
From where I sit, these changes are helpful for law-abiding people navigating a system they didn’t ask for. They will save time, reduce mistakes, and eliminate one risky local touchpoint. But they don’t cure the foundational problem that turns a right into a permission slip.
Use the smoother path if you must. Keep pushing for a world where the path isn’t needed.
UP NEXT: “Heavily Armed” — See Which States Are The Most Strapped
Image Credit: Survival World
Americans have long debated the role of firearms, but one thing is sure — some states are far more armed than others. See where your state ranks in this new report on firearm ownership across the U.S.
Mark grew up in the heart of Texas, where tornadoes and extreme weather were a part of life. His early experiences sparked a fascination with emergency preparedness and homesteading. A father of three, Mark is dedicated to teaching families how to be self-sufficient, with a focus on food storage, DIY projects, and energy independence. His writing empowers everyday people to take small steps toward greater self-reliance without feeling overwhelmed.
