Finding the perfect concealed carry gun in today’s oversaturated market can feel like an impossible task. With so many options – some excellent, others questionable – it’s easy to get lost in the noise. That’s why we’re breaking down seven of the best and worst carry guns available, giving you the details you need to make an informed decision. Some of these guns are top-tier choices for everyday carry, while others fall short due to poor design, capacity issues, or lackluster performance.
1. The Sig Sauer P365 – The Micro-Compact Champion

The Sig Sauer P365 changed the game when it first hit the market, setting a new standard for micro-compacts. Before its arrival, small 9mm pistols typically had a capacity of 6 or 7 rounds, but the P365 upped the ante with a 10+1 standard magazine while maintaining a slim, easy-to-conceal profile. The trigger is crisp, the grip texture provides excellent control, and the X-ray night sights make target acquisition easier in low-light situations.
If you want even more from this platform, the P365 XL and P365 X-Macro offer extended capacity and enhanced features, making them ideal for those who prioritize shootability while still maintaining a small footprint.
2. Springfield Hellcat Pro – A Versatile Contender

The Springfield Hellcat Pro is another fantastic choice for concealed carry, offering a 15+1 capacity in a thin and compact frame. The adaptive grip texture makes it comfortable for both inside-the-waistband and outside-the-waistband carry, while the optics-ready slide and high-visibility sights provide quick target acquisition.
While slightly larger than some other micro-compacts, the Hellcat Pro strikes a balance between size, firepower, and comfort. It works well as an everyday carry pistol or even as a home defense option when paired with a light and optic.
3. Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus – The Budget-Friendly Performer

For those looking for the best bang for their buck, the M&P Shield Plus is a top-tier choice. It delivers a 10, 13, or 15-round capacity depending on the magazine, a flat-faced trigger for improved control, and an ergonomic grip that makes shooting comfortable.
One of the biggest advantages of the Shield Plus is its versatility. It’s small enough to carry comfortably, yet large enough to be a viable option for those who prefer a slightly more substantial feel in their hands. The availability of performance center models with improved triggers and optics-ready configurations adds even more appeal.
4. Glock 43X – A Disappointing Entry from Glock

The Glock 43X was meant to compete with the Sig P365 and Hellcat, but unfortunately, it falls short in a few key areas. With a 10+1 capacity in a frame that’s larger than its competitors, it feels like a missed opportunity. The trigger is less refined than other Glock models, and the factory sights are lackluster.
While it’s not necessarily a terrible gun, there are simply better options on the market for those looking for a slim, high-capacity concealed carry pistol. Glock fans might still appreciate the platform, but compared to what else is available, the 43X feels outdated.
5. Taurus GX4XL – A Surprising Budget-Friendly Contender

Taurus has had a mixed reputation in the gun world, but the GX4XL is a shockingly good entry in the concealed carry category. Featuring a longer barrel for improved accuracy, solid ergonomics, and an excellent trigger, this pistol punches well above its price range.
Taurus also made sure to include optics-ready options, something that’s becoming a must-have feature in today’s market. While some might still hesitate due to Taurus’ history, the GX4XL has proven itself to be a reliable and accurate carry gun.
6. KelTec P15 – A Gun with Too Many Flaws

KelTec is known for taking risks with innovative designs, but the P15 is a prime example of a gun that just doesn’t deliver. While it boasts a 15-round capacity in a small frame, the extreme lightweight design results in excessive recoil, making follow-up shots more difficult.
Additionally, the aggressive grip texture makes it uncomfortable for inside-the-waistband carry, and the gun isn’t optics-ready, despite looking like it should be. Overall, while KelTec deserves credit for trying something different, the P15 is a gun that’s difficult to recommend for everyday carry.
7. Stoeger STR-9C – A Forgettable Option

Stoeger, a company known for shotguns, ventured into the striker-fired pistol market with the STR-9C. While the gun itself isn’t outright terrible, it doesn’t offer anything special. The adjustable sights, decent grip texture, and acceptable trigger aren’t enough to make it stand out in a crowded field of exceptional carry guns.
The biggest downside? The poorly designed slide serrations make racking the gun difficult, especially in wet or stressful conditions. When compared to similarly priced pistols like the Shield Plus or GX4XL, the STR-9C simply doesn’t hold up.
How to Choose the Best Concealed Carry Gun for You

Choosing the right concealed carry gun isn’t just about getting the most rounds or the best features – it’s about finding a pistol that you can shoot well, carry comfortably, and trust in a defensive situation. The best way to decide is to handle and shoot multiple options before making a purchase.
Factors like trigger feel, grip ergonomics, weight, and recoil management all play significant roles in how effective a carry gun will be for you personally.
Does Size Matter in Concealed Carry?

One of the most common debates in concealed carry is whether smaller is always better. While a tiny gun is easier to conceal, it often comes with trade-offs like lower capacity, increased recoil, and a less comfortable grip.
For most people, the ideal carry gun is one that strikes a balance between concealability and shootability. Guns like the P365 XL, Hellcat Pro, and Shield Plus prove that you don’t have to sacrifice performance for size.
Why Optics Are Becoming Essential for Carry Guns

Red dots on handguns were once considered a niche feature, but they’ve now become a game-changer for defensive shooting. Optics allow for faster target acquisition, better accuracy under stress, and improved shooting in low-light conditions.
With many of the best concealed carry guns now coming optics-ready, it’s worth considering a pistol that allows you to mount a red dot – even if you don’t plan on using one immediately.
The Best Gun Is the One You Trust

At the end of the day, the best concealed carry gun is the one you trust to perform when you need it most. Whether that’s the P365, Shield Plus, or Hellcat Pro, the key is to train regularly, carry consistently, and choose a firearm that fits your personal needs.
Before making your decision, take the time to rent and shoot different models at the range. The gun that feels best in your hand and inspires confidence will always be the best choice – regardless of what’s trending in the market.

Gary’s love for adventure and preparedness stems from his background as a former Army medic. Having served in remote locations around the world, he knows the importance of being ready for any situation, whether in the wilderness or urban environments. Gary’s practical medical expertise blends with his passion for outdoor survival, making him an expert in both emergency medical care and rugged, off-the-grid living. He writes to equip readers with the skills needed to stay safe and resilient in any scenario.