Skip to Content

300 Blackout vs. 5.56: Which One’s the Real Heavy Hitter?

When it comes to choosing between the 300 Blackout and the 5.56 NATO, many firearm enthusiasts are left wondering which one is truly the superior round. Both cartridges have their unique advantages, but they are often suited to different scenarios. From hunting to home defense, each round has its strengths and weaknesses. In this article, we’ll break down both cartridges to help you figure out which one is the real heavy hitter for your needs.

Overview: What Sets Them Apart?

Overview What Sets Them Apart
Image Credit: Survival World

The 300 Blackout and 5.56 NATO rounds are quite different despite being commonly compared. The 5.56 NATO is known for its speed and long-range performance, while the 300 Blackout shines in close-quarters engagements, especially when used with a suppressor. The size and ballistic characteristics of these rounds make them suited for different roles, making it important to understand what each one brings to the table.

Power and Ballistics

Power and Ballistics
Image Credit: Survival World

The 300 Blackout is designed to deliver heavy-hitting power, especially at close range. With supersonic and subsonic options, it can be tailored for different tasks, but one thing’s for sure – it packs a punch. The 5.56 NATO, on the other hand, relies on speed rather than sheer mass. Its lighter bullet travels faster, making it effective at longer ranges but with less stopping power than the 300 Blackout at close range.

Suppression and Stealth

Suppression and Stealth
Image Credit: Survival World

One of the 300 Blackout’s biggest advantages is its ability to perform exceptionally well when suppressed, particularly with subsonic ammunition. In contrast, the 5.56 NATO is notoriously loud and harder to suppress effectively. If you’re looking for a quiet option for tactical situations or home defense, the 300 Blackout with a suppressor is hard to beat. In fact, many people choose this round specifically for its quiet firing capabilities.

Barrel Length and Versatility

Barrel Length and Versatility
Image Credit: Survival World

The 300 Blackout was engineered to perform well out of shorter barrels. This makes it a great option for pistols and short-barreled rifles, where the round can still achieve effective terminal ballistics. Meanwhile, the 5.56 NATO shines in longer barrels, typically 16 inches or more, where it can reach its full velocity potential. For those looking to use a shorter firearm for maneuverability, the 300 Blackout is often the better choice.

Ammo Availability and Cost

Ammo Availability and Cost
Image Credit: Survival World

While both rounds are popular, 5.56 NATO ammo is more widely available and generally cheaper. The 5.56 is easier to find on the shelves, especially during high demand. In a post-apocalyptic scenario or even just a simple ammo run, you’re more likely to come across 5.56. However, the gap is closing as 300 Blackouts become more popular, but for now, the cost and availability still favor 5.56 NATO.

Range and Accuracy

Range and Accuracy
Image Credit: Survival World

When it comes to longer-range engagements, the 5.56 NATO shines. Its higher velocity allows it to maintain a flatter trajectory and better accuracy at distances beyond 300 yards. The 300 Blackout, while powerful, is better suited for engagements under 300 yards due to its slower speed and heavier bullet. The 5.56 is the obvious choice for long-range shooters, but if your typical range is under 200 yards, the 300 Blackout can still be incredibly effective.

Penetration and Impact

Penetration and Impact
Image Credit: Banana Ballistics

In testing conducted by Banana Ballistics, the 5.56 NATO outperformed the 300 Blackout when it came to penetration power, particularly against mild steel. Using a 16-inch barrel, the 5.56 managed to create a clean hole in a 1/4-inch steel plate, while the 300 Blackout struggled to achieve similar results, especially with subsonic rounds. Even with supersonic 300 Blackout rounds, the penetration was significantly less impressive, only denting the steel without passing through.

This test highlights a crucial difference between the two rounds: while the 300 Blackout is optimized for close-range engagements and suppressed firing, it lacks the raw penetrating ability of the 5.56 when it comes to tougher barriers. For situations requiring penetration through barriers like metal or heavy materials, the 5.56 clearly has the edge, showcasing its advantage in scenarios that demand deeper impact and higher velocity.

Hunting Applications

Hunting Applications
Image Credit: Survival World

For hunting, the choice between 300 Blackout and 5.56 often depends on the game you’re targeting. The 300 Blackout is highly favored for hog hunting and other medium-sized game due to its stopping power and heavier bullet. As noted in the first source, when using supersonic rounds, the 300 Blackout can drop larger animals more effectively than the 5.56. The 5.56, however, is better suited for smaller game and varmints due to its speed and accuracy.

Home Defense: Which One Reigns Supreme?

Home Defense Which One Reigns Supreme
Image Credit: Survival World

Choosing a home defense round can be tricky, but both rounds have their merits. The 300 Blackout’s ability to stay quiet when suppressed makes it a top choice for indoor scenarios, where noise control might be important. However, the 5.56’s lighter recoil and faster follow-up shots make it easier to control, which is crucial in high-stress situations. For those prioritizing stealth and punch, the 300 Blackout might be better, but the 5.56 offers faster engagement capabilities.

Tactical Use and Close-Quarter Combat

Tactical Use and Close Quarters Combat
Image Credit: Survival World

In close-quarters combat (CQC), the 300 Blackout truly shines. Its heavier bullet and ability to retain power in shorter barrels make it ideal for CQC scenarios. The subsonic rounds in particular allow for quieter engagements, which can be critical in tactical situations. The 5.56, while faster, doesn’t have the same impact in CQC, especially when used in shorter barrels where its velocity advantage is reduced.

Adaptability and Platforms

Adaptability and Platforms
Image Credit: Survival World

One of the greatest strengths of both rounds is their adaptability in the AR-15 platform. You can easily swap between a 300 Blackout upper and a 5.56 upper without changing the lower receiver. This versatility means that with a single rifle, you can switch between the two rounds depending on the situation. If you’re debating which one to invest in, you can always have both and swap out as needed.

Verdict: Which One is the Real Heavy Hitter?

Verdict Which One is the Real Heavy Hitter
Image Credit: Survival World

At the end of the day, the 300 Blackout and the 5.56 NATO both serve their purposes well. The 300 Blackout is the real heavy hitter when it comes to power, suppression, and close-quarters situations. Its versatility in different environments, especially with short-barrel firearms, gives it a distinct advantage. However, for long-range engagements, ammo availability, and ease of use, the 5.56 NATO reigns supreme. Your choice ultimately comes down to your needs – whether you prioritize power or precision.

No Clear Winner

No Clear Winner
Image Credit: Survival World

In the debate of 300 Blackout vs. 5.56, there isn’t a clear winner. Both rounds excel in different areas, and the best choice depends on your intended use. Whether you’re planning for home defense, hunting, or a tactical mission, knowing the strengths and limitations of each round is key to making the right decision.