Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Preparedness

“Hey buddy, you’re in my spot.”: Hunter claiming his spot on public land leads to a criminal charge

Hey buddy, you're in my spot. Hunter claiming his spot on public land leads to a criminal charge
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

A Florida hunting dispute in the Everglades turned into a criminal citation after officers said one man crossed the line from frustration over a hunting spot into unlawful interference with another person’s hunt.

Bodycam footage posted by the hunting bodycam YouTube channel Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife showed Florida Fish and Wildlife officers responding to a call about a man allegedly harassing two hunters on public land. What started as a disagreement over who had a right to hunt a certain “hole” ended with the man being charged with intentionally interfering with or attempting to prevent the lawful taking of fish, game, or nongame animals.

The phrase at the center of the case was simple, but it carried a lot of weight.

“Hey buddy, you’re in my spot,” the man told officers he said when he paddled into the area and found the other hunters already there.

But as the officer later explained, that was the problem. On public land, no hunter owns a pond, a hole, or a blind location just because he hunted it before.

A Dispute In The Dark

According to the Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife host, officers were called after two hunters claimed the man had harassed them while they were legally hunting in the Florida Everglades.

When the officer arrived, he first spoke with the two hunters and asked them to write sworn statements. He told them to be detailed, especially about anything the man allegedly said that sounded threatening or anything he did that appeared aimed at ruining their hunt.

A Dispute In The Dark
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

One hunter told the officer the man approached while shouting that it was “my hole.” He said the man was yelling, cursing, using slurs, and acting “off the rails.”

The hunter also claimed the man made a gesture as if he might hit him with a paddle.

The officer asked whether there had been any physical contact. The hunter said there had not, but he described the encounter as threatening and said he had kept his gun unloaded, with the action open, while trying to avoid making the situation worse.

That detail matters because the whole scene took place in the dark, around hunters carrying firearms, in a remote area where tempers were rising. Even if no one touches anyone, a loud confrontation in that setting can become dangerous very quickly.

“This Is Public Land, Man”

The hunter told the officer that he and his hunting partner had put in the time to scout the area, just like anyone else.

He said the man seemed angry that someone else was already hunting where he wanted to hunt. According to the hunter, the man asked what time he had to wake up to get to “my hole” and questioned whether they had seen him hunting there before.

The hunter said his response was that the area was public land.

“This is public land, man,” he told the officer. “You can’t claim this.”

That is the core of the case.

Public hunting land can create awkward situations because people often scout the same places, return to the same ponds, and feel attached to spots where they have had success. But attachment is not ownership.

That can be hard for people to accept, especially when they wake up early, haul gear through rough country, and find someone else already set up. Still, the law does not turn a public hole into private property because someone hunted it last weekend.

The Other Hunter Gives His Side

The officer then spoke with the man accused of interference, later addressed in the footage as Mr. Lawson.

Lawson told the officer the situation was a misunderstanding. He said he paddled out to the pond he had hunted the previous weekend and saw lights come on.

He said he told the other hunters, “Hey buddy, you’re in my spot.”

The Other Hunter Gives His Side
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

Lawson admitted he had told them it was his pond and said he had hunted there before. But he also said he understood it was public land and claimed he moved to the next pond after the confrontation.

“I wasn’t trying to ruin the man’s hunt,” Lawson told the officer. “I’m 66 years old. I wasn’t trying to ruin the man’s hunt.”

Lawson claimed the other hunter had a gun in his hand and that he was scared. He said the gun was “flopping around” in his face, but when the officer pressed him on whether the hunter had actually shouldered or pointed the shotgun at him, Lawson backed away from that claim.

“No, he did not mount a shotgun to his shoulder,” Lawson said.

That exchange was important. The officer reminded him that a sworn statement had to be truthful and that there was a big difference between saying someone had a gun while hunting and saying they pointed it at him in a threatening way.

Sworn Statements And A Refusal To Write

The officer asked Lawson to write a statement explaining his side of the story.

Lawson declined.

He said he had already told the officer what happened and did not have much more to say. The officer explained that even without physical violence, the “territorial stuff” was an issue because the land was public.

That is where the situation began to turn against Lawson.

According to the officer, the other hunters were willing to provide sworn written statements. Lawson, after giving a calmer version of events verbally, did not want to put his side under oath.

The officer later told the hunters that Lawson’s story was different at first, but when asked to write it or give it under oath, he “kind of changed up and didn’t want to say anything.”

That does not automatically prove someone is guilty, of course. People may decline to write statements for many reasons. But in a field investigation, when one side provides detailed sworn statements and video while the other side refuses to document his version, it can affect how the officer weighs the evidence.

Video Evidence Added To The Case

One of the hunters told the officer they also had video from the encounter.

The hunter said the video showed Lawson leaving the hole while shining a spotlight and cursing at them. The officer asked for the video to be sent by email or text so he could include it with the case.

Video Evidence Added To The Case
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

After reviewing the hunters’ statements and the video, the officer said he was going to charge Lawson with intentionally interfering with a person’s lawful attempt to take game.

“It’s pretty much just hunter harassment,” the officer told the hunters. “It’s a criminal offense.”

The officer also encouraged the hunters not to stop using the area because of Lawson. He told them they could hunt any hole they wanted, but if Lawson came into their area again, they should call immediately and avoid engaging him.

That was good practical advice. In public land conflicts, even people who are right can make things worse by arguing in the dark with armed strangers. Calling officers early is usually safer than trying to win the argument face-to-face.

“You Can’t Claim A Hole Is Yours”

When the officer returned to Lawson, he handed him a citation and explained the charge.

“Today you are being issued a citation,” the officer said. “It’s going to be a misdemeanor charge for interference with people attempting to take game.”

Then he laid out the rule plainly.

“This is public area,” the officer said. “You can’t claim a hole is yours. You can’t tell people that it’s your hole.”

Lawson was shocked.

“No way, dude,” he said. “You got to be kidding me.”

He argued that the other hunter should also be going to court, but the officer said the other hunter had not committed a crime that day. Lawson insisted he had moved to the next pond and said the situation was only a verbal confrontation.

“It was a verbal confrontation,” Lawson said. “And I moved out.”

The officer responded that the problem was the confrontation happened during a lawful hunt and that Lawson had interfered with them, while they had not interfered with him.

That distinction is important. A public land disagreement may begin with both sides irritated, but the law focuses on conduct. If one person approaches others, claims the spot, yells, curses, shines a light, or does anything meant to disrupt the hunt, that can become more than just bad manners.

The Case Took A Strange Turn In Court

The Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife host explained that Lawson was charged with intentionally interfering with or attempting to prevent the lawful taking of fish, game, or nongame animals.

But the court process became complicated.

The Case Took A Strange Turn In Court
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

Although the bodycam footage and arrest report indicated the incident happened in Palm Beach County, the case was initially tried in Broward County. During the non-jury trial, the State presented witnesses before resting its case, and the defense argued lack of venue.

The judge found Lawson not guilty.

Before that ruling, according to the host, the State had already filed the same charge in Palm Beach County based on the same incident. The defense moved to dismiss that case, arguing it violated double jeopardy.

The court agreed, finding the Broward case had been a full trial on the merits, and dismissed the Palm Beach case.

That ending is legally interesting because it shows the difference between what happened in the field and what survives in court. The officer believed there was enough evidence for a charge. The later court issue turned not on whether the conduct was polite or proper, but on venue and double jeopardy.

A Public Land Lesson For Every Hunter

The bodycam footage is a reminder that public land only works when everyone accepts the same basic rule: first there is not the same as forever.

A hunter can scout a spot, hunt it for years, and feel like it is his place. He can know the birds, the water, the trails, and the best approach in the dark. But unless it is private land, someone else can get there first.

That reality can be frustrating. It can ruin a morning. It can feel unfair.

But it does not give anyone the right to claim the spot, shout someone down, shine lights into their setup, or make them feel threatened while they are lawfully hunting.

The officer summed it up best when he told Lawson that the area was public and he could not claim the hole as his.

That simple rule could have saved everyone a lot of trouble. Lawson could have paddled to another pond without the confrontation. The other hunters could have continued their hunt. Officers would not have had to sort through statements, videos, and accusations before sunrise.

Instead, a dispute over “my spot” became a criminal charge, a court fight, and a lesson that public land belongs to everyone, not just the person who got used to being there first.

You May Also Like

News

Image Credit: Max Velocity - Severe Weather Center