Skip to Content

Double Barrel Shotguns Are NOT Good For Home Defense

When it comes to choosing a firearm for home defense, the image of a double-barrel shotgun might seem like a solid option. However, while it holds a certain charm and nostalgic appeal, using a double-barrel shotgun for home defense has more drawbacks than benefits. Let’s explore why this old-school firearm might not be the best choice when protecting your home and loved ones.

Limited Capacity: Only Two Shots

Limited Capacity Only Two Shots
Image Credit: Survival World

The most obvious disadvantage of a double-barrel shotgun is its limited capacity. With only two shots before needing to reload, you’re at a significant disadvantage in a home defense scenario where multiple shots may be necessary. Reddit user Albino_Echidna pointed out that while a double barrel can be effective, having to fumble with loading after just two shots in the heat of the moment could prove disastrous. In contrast, modern home defense firearms like semi-automatic shotguns or handguns offer much higher capacities, allowing for more sustained defense.

Slow Reloading Under Pressure

Slow Reloading Under Pressure
Image Credit: Survival World

Reloading a double-barrel shotgun is not only slow but also tricky, especially under the stress of a home invasion. In a tense situation, every second counts, and trying to reload a break-action shotgun can be more complicated than expected. Reddit user u/Kv603 mentioned that reloading a double-barrel shotgun in the dark with adrenaline pumping through your veins is a serious challenge. By the time you’ve reloaded, the threat could have escalated significantly.

High Recoil and Difficulty of Use

High Recoil and Difficulty of Use
Image Credit: Survival World

Double barrel shotguns, particularly in 12 gauge, pack a heavy punch. The recoil can be intense, especially for someone who isn’t well-practiced. This high recoil makes it harder to get back on target after firing, especially if the user is smaller or inexperienced. Reddit user u/Vjornaxx emphasized that while shotguns are powerful, their heavy recoil and difficult handling, particularly for women or smaller individuals, can make them harder to manage in a high-stress situation.

Two Triggers or One? Neither is Ideal

Two Triggers or One Neither is Ideal
Image Credit: Survival World

Many double-barrel shotguns come with two triggers, one for each barrel, which is a design that might confuse someone under pressure. In a home defense situation, having to think about which trigger to pull adds complexity that simply isn’t needed. Even with single trigger models, there is often a tang or selector switch to choose which barrel to fire next. As Reddit user BeneficialTrash6 noted, this is far from ideal in a stressful situation where the last thing you want to worry about is which barrel is ready to fire next.

Handling and Maneuverability Indoors

Handling and Maneuverability Indoors
Image Credit: Survival World

In tight spaces like hallways or small rooms, the long barrels of most double-barrel shotguns make them cumbersome to maneuver. Reddit user ApartRuin5962 pointed out that long guns, especially double-barrel shotguns, can be awkward to use indoors. In contrast, shorter firearms like handguns or even tactical shotguns with shorter barrels are easier to handle and aim in confined spaces, making them better suited for home defense.

Lack of Customization Options

Lack of Customization Options
Image Credit: Survival World

Double-barrel shotguns lack the versatility and customization options of modern firearms. Home defense weapons benefit from accessories like mounted flashlights, laser sights, or optics, which can greatly improve accuracy and target identification in low-light conditions. Unfortunately, most double-barrel shotguns aren’t designed to accommodate these upgrades, leaving you at a disadvantage when trying to identify threats in the dark. User Vjornaxx added that modern home defense setups with tactical additions like flashlights can make all the difference in stressful situations, something a double-barrel shotgun can’t easily provide.

Over-Penetration: A Real Concern

Over Penetration A Real Concern
Image Credit: Survival World

One of the major concerns when using a shotgun for home defense is over-penetration. Shotguns, especially when loaded with buckshot or slugs, can blast through walls, posing a risk to other occupants of the home or even neighbors. While some people suggest using birdshot to reduce this risk, Reddit user 762jeremy correctly noted that birdshot is far too weak for reliable stopping power. The balance between stopping power and over-penetration is tricky with shotguns, and double-barrel models don’t offer much flexibility in terms of ammunition selection.

Alternatives: Better Choices for Home Defense

Alternatives Better Choices for Home Defense
Image Credit: Survival World

If you’re set on using a shotgun for home defense, a pump-action or semi-automatic shotgun offers better capacity, faster follow-up shots, and easier handling. These shotguns are designed for more practical home defense use, with higher magazine capacities and smoother reloading. Alternatively, AR-15-style rifles and handguns are frequently recommended as better options for home defense due to their ease of use, lower recoil, and higher round capacities. Reddit user u/Vjornaxx pointed out that an AR-15 is easier to handle, quicker to reload, and offers more rounds per reload, making it a superior choice over a double-barrel shotgun in most cases.

The Myth of Deterrence: The “Sound” of a Shotgun

The Myth of Deterrence The Sound of a Shotgun
Image Credit: Survival World

There’s a popular myth that the sound of racking a shotgun is enough to deter intruders. While this idea is romanticized, it’s not a reliable strategy for home defense. In fact, it gives away your position and could escalate the situation. User No_ThatGuy shared an anecdote where racking a shotgun scared off intruders, but this isn’t something you should rely on. A firearm’s primary role in home defense is to stop a threat, not to act as an intimidation tool.

Double Barrel Nostalgia vs. Practicality

Double Barrel Nostalgia vs. Practicality
Image Credit: Survival World

Double-barrel shotguns evoke a sense of nostalgia, and for many, they’re a piece of history. They’ve served hunters and sports shooters well for decades, but when it comes to modern home defense, practicality should outweigh sentimentality. As Reddit user BeneficialTrash6 pointed out, if you already own a double-barrel shotgun, it’s better than nothing, but there are far superior options available that provide more security and ease of use.

A Poor Fit for Modern Home Defense

A Poor Fit for Modern Home Defense
Image Credit: Survival World

While double-barrel shotguns have their place in sporting and hunting, they are not the best option for home defense. The limited capacity, slow reloading, high recoil, and lack of customization make them a poor fit for defending your home in a high-pressure situation. Modern firearms, whether pump-action shotguns, AR-15-style rifles, or semi-automatic handguns, offer far better performance in home defense scenarios. Before settling on a firearm to protect your home, consider the practical drawbacks of a double-barrel shotgun and explore more efficient, reliable options.