Skip to Content

Birdshot vs Grizzly: An Unbelievable True Story

The idea of stopping a grizzly bear with birdshot seems absurd at first glance. Most hunters would agree that even powerful firearms can struggle to stop these massive predators. Yet, in a remarkable turn of events in Montana, one man’s life was saved by what seemed an impossible shot. The story has captivated outdoorsmen and hunters alike, sparking debates about luck, preparation, and the limits of firepower.

The Incident That Defied All Odds

The Incident That Defied All Odds
Image Credit: Survival World

In 2003, James Beeman of Fortine, Montana, faced a terrifying encounter with a grizzly bear outside his rural home. As detailed by Dean Weingarten in AmmoLand, the early morning quiet was shattered by commotion from Beeman’s chicken coop. Thinking it was a skunk raiding his chickens, Beeman grabbed a .410 bolt-action shotgun loaded with #7 ½ birdshot – hardly the weapon anyone would choose to confront a charging grizzly.

Instead of a skunk, Beeman found himself face-to-face with a 350-pound female grizzly. As Beeman retreated, the bear dropped its stolen chicken and charged from just 15 feet away. At the last possible moment, Beeman fired from the hip, the muzzle a mere three feet from the bear’s nose. Against all odds, the bear dropped dead at his feet.

The Anatomy of a Miracle Shot

The Anatomy of a Miracle Shot
Image Credit: Survival World

According to Weingarten’s account, two tiny pellets from the birdshot traveled up the bear’s nasal cavity and into its brain, instantly killing it. This remarkable shot wasn’t about brute force; it was a combination of proximity, precision, and perhaps a bit of luck. A necropsy later confirmed the shot’s path and the bear’s cause of death.

In an interview with Cowboy State Daily, Wyoming hunter Garrett Kalkowski expressed disbelief at the feat. Kalkowski, who has personally faced a grizzly charge, called the event “insane” but acknowledged that the close range allowed the shot to act as a compact mass, giving it the penetration needed to be lethal.

Birdshot’s Role in Bear Encounters

Birdshot’s Role in Bear Encounters
Image Credit: Survival World

Birdshot is designed for small game, not large predators. As Mark Heinz reported in Cowboy State Daily, even seasoned outdoorsmen find it hard to believe that such a light load could stop a grizzly. At greater distances, birdshot spreads too much to be effective against a bear’s thick hide and muscle. But as Kalkowski noted, at near-point-blank range, the shot remains concentrated, acting almost like a slug.

The Context of the Encounter

The Context of the Encounter
Image Credit: Survival World

Beeman’s decision to use a .410 shotgun wasn’t based on preparation for a bear encounter. As Weingarten explained, he believed he was dealing with a skunk and didn’t want to risk damaging his chicken coop with a larger firearm. The choice of a .410 was practical for the task at hand but turned out to be an improbable lifesaver.

In hindsight, it’s easy to question Beeman’s choice, but as Heinz pointed out, the reality of living in grizzly country means surprises are always possible. Grizzlies are a constant presence in parts of Montana, and their adaptability makes them both fascinating and dangerous.

A Testament to Steady Nerves

A Testament to Steady Nerves
Image Credit: Survival World

What’s perhaps most remarkable about this story is Beeman’s composure under pressure. Kalkowski told Cowboy State Daily that such an encounter would test anyone’s nerves. The ability to stay steady and fire accurately in such a moment speaks to Beeman’s instincts and presence of mind.

Chuke from Chuke’s Outdoor Adventures echoed similar sentiments in his video recounting the story. He emphasized how rare it is for such a shot to succeed and how Beeman’s quick thinking saved his life.

The Importance of Shot Placement

The Importance of Shot Placement
Image Credit: Survival World

Both Chuke and Kalkowski agree that the key to Beeman’s survival was shot placement. While birdshot is far from ideal for bear defense, the pellets that entered the bear’s brain made all the difference. As Chuke noted, even more powerful firearms can fail to stop a bear if the shot isn’t placed correctly.

Historical Precedents

Historical Precedents
Image Credit: Survival World

While Beeman’s story is extraordinary, it’s not entirely unique. As Heinz pointed out, there have been other instances of bears being killed with small calibers or light loads, though these cases are exceedingly rare. One notable example is Bella Twin, a 63-year-old Cree woman who killed a record-breaking grizzly with a .22 rifle in 1953.

These stories serve as reminders that, while equipment matters, skill and circumstance often play a larger role in survival situations.

A Lesson for the Outdoors

A Lesson for the Outdoors
Image Credit: Survival World

Beeman’s experience highlights the unpredictable nature of wildlife encounters. While birdshot worked in this instance, it’s far from a reliable solution. As Weingarten noted, a larger firearm loaded with slugs or hardcast bullets is the gold standard for bear defense. Electric fences and proper food storage also play critical roles in preventing such encounters.

The Intersection of Luck and Preparation

The Intersection of Luck and Preparation
Image Credit: Survival World

As remarkable as Beeman’s story is, it’s hard not to marvel at the sheer luck involved. The odds of those two pellets finding their way into the bear’s brain were astronomically low. At the same time, Beeman’s ability to act decisively under pressure is a testament to his preparedness and resilience.

This tale serves as both inspiration and cautionary tale for those who venture into bear country. It underscores the importance of carrying the right tools and maintaining situational awareness, while also reminding us that sometimes, luck can be the deciding factor.

The Role of Myth in Outdoor Culture

The Role of Myth in Outdoor Culture
Image Credit: Survival World

Stories like Beeman’s often take on a life of their own, becoming part of the folklore of outdoor life. As Chuke observed, these tales spark endless debates among hunters and survivalists, blending fact, legend, and speculation. While it’s important to separate myth from reality, such stories also highlight the enduring allure of the wilderness and its challenges.

Always Prepared

Always Prepared
Image Credit: Survival World

The story of James Beeman and his .410 shotgun shows us how unpredictable and often miraculous the nature of human survival can be. While it’s not a strategy anyone would recommend, his incredible shot has secured its place in the annals of outdoor lore. For those who live and hunt in bear country, the tale is both a reminder of the wilderness’s unpredictability and a call to always be prepared – for anything.

Maintaining Composure

Maintaining Composure
Image Credit: Survival World

What do you think? How would you have reacted in Beeman’s situation? Do you think you could have maintained the same level of composure under such pressure? Does Beeman’s story change your perspective on the importance of carrying the right equipment in bear country? What do you think played a bigger role in this encounter: skill, preparation, or pure luck?

To dive deeper into this topic, check out the full video on Chuke’s Outdoor Adventures YouTube channel here, and read the articles on AmmoLand here, and on Cowboy State Daily here.