America Almost Had 14 Colonies – Here’s What Happened to the Last One

Everyone learns the tidy story of the original 13 colonies. Less tidy is the tale of the colony that almost joined them: Transylvania. No capes or vampires here – just the Latin for “beyond the forest,” an apt name for a private attempt to found a British colony in the rugged country where present-day Kentucky, Virginia, and Tennessee meet. For a brief, combustible moment in 1775, Transylvania had a government, a capital, and a plan to be recognized by the Continental Congress. Then reality – legal, military, and human – caught up.

The Gate in the Mountains

The scheme hinged on geography. The Appalachians were the great wall of colonial America; the Cumberland Gap was a door in that wall. In 1750, Virginia physician-explorer Thomas Walker famously documented this low pass and named nearby rivers and ridges for the Duke of Cumberland. Long before his survey, Indigenous peoples had moved through the gap for generations. At just 1,631 feet, it threaded a line through the Cumberland Mountains and later funneled hundreds of thousands of travelers west. If the United States has an original turnstile, this was it.

Richard Henderson’s Big Bet

Enter Richard Henderson, a North Carolina judge turned land speculator with a breathtaking plan. Through his Transylvania Company, he aimed to buy roughly 20 million acres south of the Ohio River from the Cherokee and spin it into Britain’s newest colony. The Royal Proclamation of 1763 banned private settlement west of the Appalachians, and both Virginia and North Carolina claimed sovereignty over the region – so Henderson’s legal footing was… generous, let’s say. But frontier capitalism thrives on ambiguity. He proceeded anyway, treating law as something to be argued after the land was secured.

Boone Cuts a Road Through the Wild

To make the dream real, Henderson hired Daniel Boone – already a seasoned long hunter—to carve a trail through the Gap and into Kentucky. Boone and 35 axemen hacked the coarse, muddy Wilderness Road from the Holston Valley toward the Kentucky River. Shawnee war parties – who were not bound by any Cherokee sale – ambushed the party; several men were killed or wounded. Still, Boone pushed through and founded Boonesborough near today’s Lexington. It’s easy to romanticize the swinging of axes and the “whoosh” of history, but what Boone built was infrastructure. That’s nation-building by another name.

A Constitution Under the Elm

Transylvania wasn’t just a land grab; it was a paper state. In May 1775, delegates from scattered settlements convened under a huge elm at Boonesborough. In three days they adopted nine measures – an executive, a legislature, courts – the bones of a government called the Transylvania Compact. Henderson then raced east to plead for recognition. The Continental Congress declined to touch the dispute. Virginia and North Carolina had no interest in blessing a private colony carved from what they viewed as their own backcountry. Transylvania had laws and a capital, but no sovereign to say it existed.

The People Already There

Even before Congress’s brush-off, the ground under Transylvania was shaky. At the 1775 Sycamore Shoals negotiations, many Cherokee leaders agreed to sell, but Dragging Canoe, a prominent war leader, denounced the deal as the sale of “a bloody ground.” He and his followers moved south to the Chickamauga towns near present-day Chattanooga and waged a long resistance. Meanwhile, the Shawnee asserted claims north of the Kentucky River. The blunt truth: colonists treated a contested, living homeland like a spreadsheet. The land wasn’t “purchased.” It was taken amid fracture, threat, and confusion.

Life on the Wilderness Road

And yet people flooded in. By some counts, more than 200,000 pioneers – Scots-Irish, Germans, newly landed immigrants – shouldered packs and babies and trudged the Wilderness Road. The trail was too rough for wagons at first; copperheads, rattlesnakes, robbers, and raiding parties shadowed the route. Winters were brutal. One season the Kentucky River froze two feet deep and livestock died in drifts – families survived on frozen meat. Henderson himself rode west with horsemen to widen the road for wagons, but legitimacy never caught up with logistics. Many settlers simply ignored Transylvania’s authority altogether. Consent of the governed was not exactly the frontier vibe.

A Revolution at the Front Door

Then the Revolution lit the fuse. British officials in Canada, including Lt. Gov. Henry Hamilton, armed and encouraged raids against Kentucky settlements to check rebel expansion. In July 1776, just days after Jefferson’s words rang out in Philadelphia, Jemima Boone and two other girls were captured near Boonesborough; Boone led a swift pursuit and rescued them two days later. The following spring, Shawnee leader Blackfish attacked the fort. Boone took a ball in the ankle. Crops burned. Salt ran short. The settlement teetered between hanging on and vanishing.

Boone, “Big Turtle,” and the Great Bluff

In early 1778, while leading a salt-making party on the Licking River, Boone was captured by Blackfish’s warriors. Adopted according to custom, Boone took the name Sheltowee – “Big Turtle” – and spent the winter in the Shawnee towns. When Blackfish prepared a large spring assault on Boonesborough, Boone convinced him it would be better to accept a surrender than haul women and children through the Gap. Then Boone slipped away, covering roughly 160 miles in five days to warn the fort. He led a preemptive raid and helped repulse the ensuing 10-day siege in September. Frontier loyalty is always messy; Boone was court-martialed by his own side for suspected treachery and acquitted. He rarely spoke of it again.

The Paper Colony Meets Real Government

In December 1778 – three wrenching years after Boone’s axe first bit the trail – Virginia’s legislature voided the Transylvania claim. Henderson and partners received consolation lands along the Ohio near the Green River, where the town of Henderson would rise. But the private colony was over. In hindsight, it was never really viable: built on contested treaties, opposed by two colonial governments, and born in the teeth of a continental war, Transylvania was more brilliant hack than stable polity. The continent’s future would be surveyed by states and, soon, a federal government, not by a company charter.

Boone’s Long Afterlife

Boone didn’t go back to Boonesborough. He founded Boone Station and tried his hand as a land locator – collecting large sums to file claims in Williamsburg, only to have the cash stolen as he slept. He spent years making aggrieved settlers whole. Even so, Boone became a pillar: promoted to lieutenant colonel in the Fayette County militia, a delegate to the Virginia Assembly (he was briefly captured by the British en route and released), and a veteran of hard fights like Blue Licks, where his son Israel fell. He closed his days on the Missouri frontier and died in 1820 at eighty-five, less a myth than a man who kept moving when the map ran out.

From Warpath to National Park

The Gap, once a gauntlet, is now a museum of its own past. Cumberland Gap National Historical Park was established in 1940 and dedicated on July 4, 1959 – a fitting birthday for the nation’s first true doorway to the West. For decades U.S. 25E hugged the old route so closely that locals called its deadly curves “Massacre Mountain.” In 1996, a pair of tunnels bored under the ridge shifted traffic out of the park and let the old trace breathe again. Today the site offers waterfalls, cave tours, high overlooks, Civil War traces, a preserved high-ridge settlement, campgrounds, and miles of trail – some of them scarcely wider than Boone’s original cut.

What the Failed 14th Teaches Us

Transylvania failed as a colony, but it succeeded in changing the country. The Wilderness Road became a migration highway; the Cumberland Gap a national metaphor. The episode reveals a lot about how America actually grew: on bold private schemes, shaky legal claims, Indigenous resistance, improvised governance, and relentless movement. 

My take? The story isn’t a tidy morality play. It’s a cautionary chapter about who gets to draw borders – and who gets drawn inside them – wrapped around a very American truth: build a road through a wall, and people will walk it. The “14th colony” never made the flag, but its trail helped define the nation that would.

UP NEXT: “Heavily Armed” — See Which States Are The Most Strapped

Americans have long debated the role of firearms, but one thing is sure — some states are far more armed than others.

See where your state ranks in this new report on firearm ownership across the U.S.