Skip to Content

Small Dogs vs. Big Dogs For Hiking Companions

When it comes to hiking, having a canine companion can make the journey even more rewarding. But is a small dog or a big dog better suited for the trail? Both have their advantages and drawbacks, and the decision often comes down to personal preference and hiking goals. Let’s take a closer look at how these two sizes of furry friends compare in key areas of hiking and backpacking.

Ease of Rescue: The Small Dog Advantage

Ease of Rescue The Small Dog Advantage
Image Credit: Survival World

One of the biggest concerns for hikers is what happens if their dog gets injured on the trail. Small dogs shine in this area because they’re much easier to carry. A lightweight pup can even ride on top of your backpack without adding too much strain. Big dogs, on the other hand, can pose a significant challenge. If a large dog gets hurt, you might need specialized rescue gear or assistance, making it more complicated to get them to safety.

Toughness in Cold Weather: Big Dogs Take the Lead

Toughness in Cold Weather Big Dogs Take the Lead
Image Credit: Survival World

Larger dogs generally handle cold weather better than their smaller counterparts. Due to their lower surface-area-to-volume ratio, they retain heat more efficiently and don’t lose body warmth as quickly. Small dogs are more susceptible to chilly conditions and may need extra layers, like coats or sweaters, to stay comfortable on frosty trails.

Navigating Tough Terrain: A Mixed Bag

Navigating Tough Terrain A Mixed Bag
Image Credit: Survival World

When it comes to scrambling over rocks or leaping across logs, the size of your dog can make a difference. Big dogs have the strength and agility to overcome large obstacles, but if they need help, lifting or supporting them can be difficult. Small dogs, while easier to carry, often struggle with big gaps or steep climbs. Each size has its pros and cons depending on the type of terrain you’ll be hiking.

Gear and Food Requirements: Small Dogs Win

Gear and Food Requirements Small Dogs Win
Image Credit: Survival World

Packing for a small dog is significantly easier. They require less food, smaller gear, and can even share your tent or sleeping bag. Big dogs, on the other hand, need a lot more supplies, including larger portions of food and more space to rest. For long-distance hikes or thru-hikes, the additional weight of a big dog’s food and gear can be a serious consideration.

Carrying Their Own Weight: A Big Dog Advantage

Carrying Their Own Weight A Big Dog Advantage
Image Credit: Survival World

While small dogs can’t carry much, big dogs can often shoulder some of the load. With the right pack, a large dog can carry 10-15% of its body weight, which can help lighten your load on extended trips. However, not all large dogs enjoy carrying packs, so this benefit depends on the individual dog’s temperament and physical condition.

Travel Flexibility: Small Dogs Shine

Travel Flexibility Small Dogs Shine
Image Credit: Survival World

If your hiking adventures involve air travel or hotel stays, small dogs are much easier to manage. They can often travel in the cabin of planes and are more likely to be welcomed in hotels or other accommodations. Big dogs, while lovable, can pose logistical challenges when traveling to distant trails.

Safety and Security: Big Dogs Offer Peace of Mind

Safety and Security Big Dogs Offer Peace of Mind
Image Credit: Survival World

Large dogs have a commanding presence that can deter potential threats, whether it’s wildlife or strangers. Their size and bark provide a sense of security that small dogs might not offer. While small dogs can be alert and feisty, their stature makes them more vulnerable to predators like coyotes.

Energy and Stamina: It Depends on the Breed

Energy and Stamina It Depends on the Breed
Image Credit: Survival World

Both small and big dogs can have incredible energy levels, but this largely depends on the breed and conditioning. A well-trained small dog can keep up with most hikes, but larger breeds bred for endurance might have the edge on longer or more strenuous trails.

Maintenance and Cleanup: The Small Dog Advantage

Maintenance and Cleanup The Small Dog Advantage
Image Credit: Survival World

With smaller food portions come smaller… well, cleanups. Big dogs leave bigger messes, which can add an extra layer of effort when practicing Leave No Trace principles. For hikers who value efficiency, this might tip the scales in favor of smaller companions.

Compatibility with Hikers’ Lifestyles

Compatibility with Hikers’ Lifestyles
Image Credit: Survival World

Ultimately, the best hiking companion is the one that fits your lifestyle. If you’re looking for a low-maintenance, portable partner, a small dog might be your best bet. If you value the added security and utility of a big dog, their larger size could be worth the extra effort.

It’s About the Bond

It’s About the Bond
Image Credit: Survival World

What stands out most is how adaptable dogs of all sizes can be. While big dogs might be better suited to some challenges and small dogs excel in others, the most important factor is the bond you share with your pet. A dog that trusts and loves you will go to great lengths to make your outdoor adventures unforgettable, regardless of its size.

Choose What Works for You

Choose What Works for You
Image Credit: Survival World

There’s no definitive answer to the small dog versus big dog debate for hiking companions. Both offer unique benefits and challenges. The key is to consider your hiking goals, the terrain you plan to tackle, and your dog’s breed, health, and personality. With proper preparation and care, dogs of any size can become the ultimate adventure buddy, ready to conquer the trails by your side.