Michigan’s deer hunters aren’t just frustrated.
According to Lucas Pawlosky, host of The Outdoor Conquest on YouTube, they’re “fed up” from one end of the state to the other – and they’re losing trust in the people who are supposed to manage the resource they love.
In his video “Michigan Deer Hunting is Being DESTROYED By Politics! | Who’s to Blame??” Pawlosky says the problem goes way beyond a bad season or two.
He argues that political appointees, confusing regulations, and tone-deaf leadership are turning a proud hunting tradition into a slow-motion crisis.
Hunters Say They’re Treated Like Criminals
Right out of the gate, Pawlosky tells viewers he was flooded with comments after his last deer video.
From the UP to the southern farm country, he says hunters wrote in to say they’re “totally fed up” with Michigan’s deer regulations and with the Department of Natural Resources.
According to Pawlosky, a big part of that anger comes from how hunters feel they’re treated in the field.
He says many commenters described encounters with DNR officers where they felt like suspects the moment a truck pulled up or a badge appeared.
Pawlosky even repeats one viewer’s line that hunting in Michigan feels like “you basically have to have a lawyer with you,” because the rules change so much it’s easy to break one by accident.
He’s careful to say that law enforcement in the outdoors is important and that the DNR’s mission of protecting wildlife and fisheries matters.
But in his view, the culture has shifted from partnership to harassment, and that shift has driven some hunters right out of the sport.
From a distance, that’s one of the most worrying parts of his story.
Once people start seeing game wardens as enemies instead of allies, it becomes much harder to manage wildlife with broad support.
The Real Power: NRC, Not Just DNR
Even with all that frustration, Pawlosky argues the DNR isn’t actually the main villain.
In his words, the “ultimate enemy in this state is not the DNR” – it’s the Natural Resources Commission, or NRC.
Pawlosky explains that the NRC is a seven-member public commission, appointed by the governor.
Right now, he notes, those appointments trace back to Governor Gretchen Whitmer and previous administrations.
According to Pawlosky, the NRC is the body that sets broad policy and decides what hunting, fishing, and trapping rules actually go into effect.
The DNR, in his telling, is the enforcement arm that carries out whatever the NRC decides.
He says the DNR can overstep in the field and treat hunters poorly, but it’s the NRC that ultimately approves things like bait bans, tag structures, and regulation changes.
Pawlosky points out that NRC meetings are public and held monthly, and he reminds viewers that hunters can show up and speak.
He also says DNR staff bring data and field reports to those meetings, but the final call still rests with the seven commissioners.
In an interesting twist, Pawlosky tells his audience that “you or I” could technically be appointed to the NRC if a future governor picked them.
He admits he’s even thought about pursuing a seat himself as a “voice of reason,” and you can hear that idea turning over in his mind as he talks.
That’s actually one of the most constructive pieces of his video.
Instead of just venting, he’s nudging hunters toward the room where the real decisions are made.
A Deer Herd Under Pressure Across The State
When Pawlosky shifts to the deer themselves, his tone gets even more serious.
He says comments from across Michigan paint a picture of a herd under different kinds of pressure depending on where you stand.
In the Upper Peninsula, Pawlosky says hunters told him the whitetail population is “damn near extinct” in some areas.
He credits a combination of harsh winters and a strong wolf population with “pretty much decimating” deer numbers up north.
In the southwest Lower Peninsula, Pawlosky says the disease EHD has hammered the herd.
He describes hunters who still see a few deer each night but refuse to shoot because they know how many animals the disease already wiped out.
According to Pawlosky, these on-the-ground observations don’t match the message coming from management.
He says the DNR is “begging” hunters to shoot more does to help balance the herd, but many hunters are ignoring that and using their own judgment instead.
From his perspective, the people in the stand are seeing a shortage of deer while the people writing the regulations keep acting like there’s still plenty to spare.
That disconnect – between the policy on paper and what hunters see in the woods – is a recurring theme in his video.
And once that trust breaks, you can’t fix it just by releasing another report or survey.
Less Access, Higher Costs, And Fewer Hunters
Pawlosky also spends a lot of time on something that isn’t strictly biological: access and money.
First, he claims that the DNR has been selling off public acres that used to be available to residents and nonresidents alike.
He says those parcels once gave regular hunters room to roam, and when they disappear, the pressure on what’s left only gets worse.
On the private land side, Pawlosky describes a landscape where “guys with fat wallets” are leasing up large tracts of farmland.
He says he’s watched places he grew up hunting – places where he worked for the farmers and had permission for years – get locked up by outside groups pooling their cash for exclusive access.
According to him, there are still farms that don’t lease, but those landowners often don’t want any hunters at all, even while they later use crop damage permits to shoot deer themselves.
Pawlosky argues that this combination of fewer public acres and more leased private ground makes it harder for everyday hunters to find good spots, especially if they don’t have much time.
Then there’s the raw cost.
Pawlosky acknowledges that hunters argued in his comments about whether a $5 tag increase is a big deal, but he says that misses the point.
He walks through the total: tags, a reliable vehicle, a bow that might run $500, arrows and broadheads that can easily add another hundred or more.
Once you add fuel, stands, clothing, and time off work, he says every arrow you let fly is a real investment.
That’s one reason he believes many hunters are reluctant to shoot does in the early bow season.
Why risk expensive archery gear on a doe, he says, when you can wait for gun season and take a cheaper slug shot instead?
In Pawlosky’s view, this economic reality mixes with the lower deer numbers and access problems to help explain why both the herd and the hunter base are shrinking.
From the outside, that logic tracks.
If hunting feels expensive, crowded, legally risky, and less productive, fewer people are going to stick with it.
The Baiting Ban And A Fight Over “Science”
One of the hottest topics in Pawlosky’s video is baiting.
He reminds viewers that baiting is banned in the Lower Peninsula but still allowed in the UP, and he openly says the policy makes “zero sense” to him.
Pawlosky grew up legally baiting deer and says those memories are some of his favorites.
He talks about watching deer come to a pile, harvesting “dozens of deer” over bait, and getting as much thrill out of that as any big-woods sit.
More importantly, he argues that baiting is a powerful tool for getting kids and new hunters into the sport.
If you can put a young hunter over a bait site and almost guarantee they’ll see deer, he says, you dramatically increase the odds they’ll want to come back.
The state’s rationale has been that concentrated bait sites help spread chronic wasting disease (CWD).
Pawlosky flatly rejects that explanation.
He tells viewers that deer are “swapping spit all the time” on natural food sources, licking branches, food plots, and crop fields.
He cites Ted Nugent’s line about apples falling under a tree – that moving those apples 50 or 100 yards to your stand somehow turns them into a disease risk when they weren’t before.
In Pawlosky’s mind, that’s regulatory nonsense.
He also points out that gas stations across Michigan are still selling bags of corn, carrots, and sugar beets by the pallet.
If baiting is so dangerous, he asks, why are those products still everywhere during deer season?
Pawlosky calls for baiting to be fully reinstated in the Lower Peninsula without any special bait permit fees.
He argues it would help hunters take more does, manage local herds more effectively, and make the season more enjoyable for people with limited time.
To be fair, wildlife biologists in different states have debated this issue for years, and the science is not as simple as either side would like it to be.
But Pawlosky’s larger point is about consistency and trust.
When rules feel arbitrary and out of touch with common sense, hunters start questioning everything else managers say.
Saving Michigan’s Deer Tradition Means Fixing The System
Despite all the criticism, Pawlosky ends his video on a hopeful, almost nostalgic note.
He encourages viewers to head to deer camp, throw on the blaze orange, and enjoy Michigan’s firearm opener, whether they tag a buck or not.
For him, the heart of this whole fight is the tradition itself – friends at camp, stories around the fire, and putting venison on the table.
He urges hunters not to obsess over antler size or what the neighbor thinks, but to remember why they started hunting in the first place.
At the same time, Pawlosky clearly believes change has to happen at the political level.
He pushes hunters to show up at NRC meetings, send emails, and, if they’re serious enough, even pursue a commission seat themselves.
In his view, the system has drifted away from real-world hunters and toward appointees and agendas that don’t pay the same price when things go wrong.
From the way he tells it, Michigan doesn’t just have a deer problem.
It has a leadership problem, a trust problem, and an access problem – all converging at once.
If people like Pawlosky are right, fixing the herd won’t just be about counting deer or tweaking tag numbers.
It will mean putting hunters back at the center of the conversation, instead of treating them like an afterthought in their own woods.
UP NEXT: “Heavily Armed” — See Which States Are The Most Strapped
Image Credit: Survival World
Americans have long debated the role of firearms, but one thing is sure — some states are far more armed than others. See where your state ranks in this new report on firearm ownership across the U.S.
The article Michigan’s Deer Crisis: How Politics and Poor Decisions Are Hurting Hunters first appeared on Survival World.
Gary’s love for adventure and preparedness stems from his background as a former Army medic. Having served in remote locations around the world, he knows the importance of being ready for any situation, whether in the wilderness or urban environments. Gary’s practical medical expertise blends with his passion for outdoor survival, making him an expert in both emergency medical care and rugged, off-the-grid living. He writes to equip readers with the skills needed to stay safe and resilient in any scenario.
