Catfishing looks simple at a glance – cast your line, sit back, and wait. But anyone who’s spent real time chasing catfish knows there’s a lot more to it. For years, I made mistakes that cost me fish, time, and plenty of frustration. Looking back, I realize a lot of the problems weren’t bad luck; they were bad habits. If you’re serious about catching more and bigger catfish, it’s time to break free of these common mistakes. Let’s get into five bad habits that could be hurting your catfishing success – and what to do instead.
1. Fishing for Ghosts
One of the biggest traps anglers fall into is returning to spots that used to be good, hoping history repeats itself. It’s easy to get nostalgic about that bend in the river where you caught a monster two summers ago. But fishing a location just because it produced once, without considering current conditions, is often a waste of time. Fish move. Conditions change. Don’t get stuck chasing memories. Focus on where the fish are now, not where they used to be.
2. Getting Hung Up on Expensive Tackle
It’s easy to believe you need top-dollar rods, reels, and gear to catch trophy catfish. But the truth is, fish don’t care if your rod cost $30 or $300. When I first started, I obsessed over having the “right” equipment and missed out on a lot of fishing time. Start with what you have. Upgrade when it makes sense, not because you think it’s a requirement to be successful. Trust me – the memories of a big fish breaking your cheap line will stick with you a lot longer than a brand-name rod sitting in the garage.
3. Expecting Monster Fish Everywhere
Another hard lesson: not every waterway holds trophy-sized catfish. I spent way too long thinking every trip should produce a 50-pounder. In reality, many lakes and rivers simply don’t have fish that big. And that’s okay. Set realistic expectations based on where you’re fishing. If a 10- or 12-pound fish is a big catch for that body of water, celebrate it. The biggest fish in a small pond is still a worthy opponent.
4. Thinking Catfish Are Always Deep
One of the most persistent myths is that you always have to fish deep for catfish. Growing up, we all heard that the deeper the water, the bigger the fish. Sometimes that’s true – but often, especially in warmer months, the best action happens in shallow water. Catfish follow baitfish, and if the bait is shallow, the catfish aren’t far behind. Don’t lock yourself into the mindset that you have to cast as far and deep as possible. Pay attention to where the food is, and the fish will be there too.
5. Fishing Where There Are No Fish
It sounds obvious, but you can’t catch fish where there are none. I wasted plenty of time casting into beautiful-looking water that simply didn’t have any catfish in it. Always take the time to research your fishing spots. Not every pond, creek, or stretch of river is home to catfish, no matter how good it looks. Look for signs of baitfish, feeding activity, or talk to local anglers. Save yourself the frustration – fish where the fish actually are.
Why Location Always Matters More Than Gear
It’s tempting to think that buying the latest rod or the fanciest bait will solve your catfishing struggles. But no piece of gear can make up for poor location. Catfish are opportunistic predators; if you aren’t near them, it doesn’t matter what you’re using. Always scout new waters carefully, pay attention to seasonal patterns, and never assume you can “make” fish show up. Success starts with finding the right environment first.
Shallow Isn’t Just for Bass
Too many anglers automatically associate shallow water with bass and overlook it for catfish. That’s a mistake. In the right conditions – especially spring, early summer, and during baitfish runs – catfish can be stacked up in surprisingly skinny water. Pay attention to temperature, baitfish activity, and current movement. If the groceries are shallow, the catfish will be too. Don’t miss out just because your instincts are telling you “deeper must be better.”
Your Rod Doesn’t Catch the Fish – You Do
Skill matters more than expensive tackle every time. A well-placed, patient, and thoughtful presentation will outfish someone with a thousand-dollar setup who doesn’t know how to read the water. Focus on honing your instincts, learning how fish behave throughout the seasons, and practicing good technique. The confidence you gain from knowing what you’re doing will catch you more catfish than any fancy piece of gear ever will.
Enjoy the Fish You Can Catch
It’s easy to get caught up in the idea that if you’re not catching a 60-pounder, you’re failing. Social media doesn’t help – everyone shows off their biggest catches, making it seem like anything less isn’t worth bragging about. The reality is, every fish caught is a success. Whether it’s a two-pound channel cat or a fifteen-pound blue cat, appreciate the moment. Fish to enjoy fishing – not to chase some unrealistic number you saw online.
Break Bad Habits and Catch More Fish
Catfishing success isn’t about having the best gear or hitting the deepest holes every time. It’s about adapting, being smart, and learning from experience. Stop fishing where there are no fish, stop chasing old memories, and stop stressing over stuff that doesn’t matter. Focus on where the fish are now, enjoy the fight you get, and you’ll have a lot more success and a lot more fun out on the water.
Gary’s love for adventure and preparedness stems from his background as a former Army medic. Having served in remote locations around the world, he knows the importance of being ready for any situation, whether in the wilderness or urban environments. Gary’s practical medical expertise blends with his passion for outdoor survival, making him an expert in both emergency medical care and rugged, off-the-grid living. He writes to equip readers with the skills needed to stay safe and resilient in any scenario.