Skip to Content

High-Shoulder Shot vs. Traditional Lung Shot: Where’s The Best Shot on a Deer

As hunting season begins, a question that often arises among hunters is where to aim for the most effective and ethical shot on a deer. For decades, the traditional lung shot has been the go-to for many, but a growing number of hunters are advocating for the high-shoulder shot. Each approach has its advantages and drawbacks, and the choice often depends on the hunter’s experience, the hunting situation, and the desired outcome. Let’s break down the anatomy, effectiveness, and ethical considerations of these two methods.

Understanding the High-Shoulder Shot

Understanding the High Shoulder Shot
Image Credit: Survival World

The high-shoulder shot is increasingly recognized for its ability to anchor a deer almost instantly. The ideal aim point is just above the shoulder, slightly forward of the leg, and just below the spine. When executed correctly, this shot causes massive trauma to the spinal cord and surrounding vital structures, leading to a quick and humane kill.

Hunters who prefer this shot often describe its effectiveness as almost “comical,” as the deer typically drops in place with no need to track it. This precision reduces the likelihood of the deer running and getting lost in dense terrain, water, or neighboring properties. However, the high-shoulder shot isn’t without risks – it requires accuracy. A shot placed too high may only graze the backstrap, causing injury rather than a clean kill.

Anatomy Matters

Anatomy Matters
Image Credit: Survival World

To fully appreciate the high-shoulder shot, it’s important to understand the deer’s anatomy. The target area is a relatively small zone that sits just below the spine and above the lungs. While this placement minimizes meat damage, the margin for error is tight. If the shot is too high, it misses the vital organs entirely; too low, and it risks passing through non-lethal areas. Hunters must carefully evaluate their skill level and confidence before opting for this method.

Advantages of the High-Shoulder Shot

Advantages of the High Shoulder Shot
Image Credit: Survival World

One of the most appealing aspects of the high-shoulder shot is its ability to immobilize the deer instantly. This prevents scenarios where the animal runs, potentially complicating retrieval. Additionally, this shot generally avoids damaging valuable meat, making it an excellent choice for hunters who want to maximize their harvest.

Another significant advantage is the minimal tracking required. Especially in rugged or challenging environments, ensuring the deer drops where it stands can save time and effort, while also reducing the risk of losing the animal entirely.

The Traditional Lung Shot: A Classic for a Reason

The Traditional Lung Shot A Classic for a Reason
Image Credit: Survival World

The lung shot has been a staple of ethical hunting for generations. The target zone is the area just behind the shoulder, aiming for the lungs or heart. This shot provides the largest margin for error, as hitting anywhere in the lung region typically results in a fatal outcome.

One key advantage of the lung shot is its accessibility – it’s a forgiving target, even for hunters who are less experienced or dealing with variable conditions like wind or distance. However, a lung-shot deer often runs after being hit, sometimes covering 20 to 100 yards before succumbing. While this isn’t usually an issue in open terrain, it can complicate retrieval in dense forests or near water.

Comparing Meat Damage

Comparing Meat Damage
Image Credit: Survival World

For hunters who value preserving as much meat as possible, the high-shoulder shot holds a clear edge. A properly placed lung shot can pass through ribs, potentially damaging sections of the chest or shoulders. On the other hand, a misplaced lung shot risks puncturing the stomach or intestines, leading to contamination and significant meat loss.

The Ethical Considerations

The Ethical Considerations
Image Credit: Survival World

Both shots are ethical when executed properly, as they aim to cause the least amount of suffering for the animal. However, the high-shoulder shot demands a higher degree of precision. Hunters must evaluate their skill level honestly before attempting it. Missing the spinal column can lead to a non-lethal injury, requiring additional shots or the risk of the animal escaping wounded.

The lung shot, while less likely to anchor the deer immediately, offers a broader margin for error. For newer hunters or those taking a shot in less-than-ideal conditions, it may be the more ethical choice.

Situational Factors

Situational Factors
Image Credit: Survival World

The best shot can depend heavily on the situation. In open fields or during hunts where tracking isn’t an issue, a lung shot may suffice. However, in areas with dense vegetation or near property boundaries, the high-shoulder shot can prevent the deer from running into inaccessible or problematic locations.

Frontal and Quartering Shots

Frontal and Quartering Shots
Image Credit: Survival World

Not every hunting scenario provides a perfect broadside view of the deer. Frontal and quartering shots require a deep understanding of anatomy and careful consideration of the shot angle. For example, a quartering-to shot may make a high-shoulder shot less viable, while a V-shaped bone near the leg can provide a new target zone for hunters aiming to penetrate the vitals effectively.

Mastering Shot Placement

Mastering Shot Placement
Image Credit: Survival World

Regardless of the method chosen, practicing shot placement is crucial. Hunters should visualize the vitals as a 3D object within the deer, adjusting their aim based on the animal’s angle and movement. Time spent at the range practicing on realistic targets can greatly improve accuracy and confidence in the field.

The Role of Experience

The Role of Experience
Image Credit: Survival World

Many seasoned hunters report transitioning to the high-shoulder shot after years of success with the lung shot. This evolution often comes from increased confidence and a desire to anchor deer more reliably. For newer hunters, starting with the traditional lung shot offers a forgiving learning curve while still achieving ethical outcomes.

Which Shot is Best?

Which Shot is Best
Image Credit: Survival World

Both the high-shoulder and lung shots have their place in a hunter’s toolkit. The high-shoulder shot excels in anchoring deer immediately and preserving meat, but it demands precision. The lung shot offers a wider margin for error, making it a reliable choice for hunters in varied conditions. Ultimately, the best shot is the one you can execute confidently and ethically, ensuring a humane and effective harvest.

Hunting is as much about preparation and practice as it is about understanding the anatomy and behavior of the animal. Whether you prefer the high-shoulder shot or the traditional lung shot, take the time to hone your skills and choose the method that aligns best with your goals and the situation at hand. Happy hunting!