‘Why was he out on the streets?’: Man accused of setting woman on fire on train has long criminal history

A shocking attack on a Chicago CTA Blue Line train is now colliding with an uncomfortable question:

How many chances did the system give Lawrence Reed before a woman ended up set on fire in front of horrified riders?

Reporters Jermont Terry and Sara Machi of CBS Chicago, along with Michelle Gallardo of ABC 7 Chicago, have been piecing together who Reed is, what happened on that train, and why he was free in the first place.

What they’ve found is a brutal crime, a terrorism charge, and a long trail of missed warning signs.

Terror On The Blue Line

According to U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros, the attack happened Monday night around 9 p.m. on an O’Hare-bound Blue Line train as it approached the Clark/Lake station downtown.

Boutros said the 26-year-old victim was simply “minding her own business and reading her phone” when Reed walked up behind her with a bottle in his hand.

Surveillance video from CTA train car No. 3236, described in a federal affidavit and summarized by CBS Chicago, allegedly shows Reed pouring a liquid over the woman’s head and body while she sits with her back toward him.

Boutros said Reed then tried to ignite the liquid.

At first, the woman fought him off and ran toward the front of the train, according to the affidavit cited by Jermont Terry.

Reed allegedly chased her, dropped the bottle, picked it up again as it was now on fire, and then used it to set her ablaze.

Boutros called the footage “difficult to watch” and “very disturbing,” as it shows the young woman engulfed in flames while Reed stands and watches.

You don’t need much imagination to picture how terrifying that train car must have been in that moment.

‘Burnt To A Crisp’: The Victim’s Fight To Survive

The affidavit, as reported by CBS Chicago, says the woman tried to put out the fire by rolling on the floor of the train.

But no one came to her aid while she was still inside the car.

Boutros said other passengers either got out of the way or watched.

When the train finally stopped at Clark/Lake, the woman was still on fire as she stumbled onto the platform and collapsed.

Witness Christopher Flores told CBS Chicago he saw her running off the train “completely engulfed in fire.”

He went over to see what was happening and said she was on the ground “crying” and “burnt to a crisp.”

According to ATF Special Agent Adam Fitzgerald, investigators later found her lying on her back with severe burns to her face and body.

Sources told CBS Chicago that more than half of her body was burned. She was rushed to Stroger Hospital, where she remains in critical condition.

Two Good Samaritans on the platform eventually helped put out the flames, Boutros said, but only after the woman had already suffered devastating injuries.

It’s hard not to think about how alone she must have felt in those seconds, burning on the floor while most people backed away.

Planned Or Random? Why Federal Prosecutors Call It Terrorism

Boutros announced that Reed has been charged federally with “committing a terrorist attack or other violence on a mass transportation system.”

That charge, under 18 U.S.C. § 1992, has never been used in Chicago before, according to ABC 7 legal analyst Gil Soffer, who spoke with Michelle Gallardo.

Boutros said both Illinois and the federal government have jurisdiction over crimes on public transit, but this case is serious enough that “now needs to be handled federally.”

CBS Chicago reports that the charge carries a possible life sentence, and if the victim dies, it could become a death-eligible case.

Investigators say this was not some spur-of-the-moment act.

CBS Chicago reports that surveillance video from a Citgo gas station on Chicago’s West Side allegedly shows Reed buying gasoline and filling a small container shortly before boarding the Blue Line at Kedzie-Homan.

From there, Fitzpatrick said, the trail leads onto the train, to the attack, and then to Clark/Lake, where Reed got off and left the scene.

He was arrested the next morning near 140 W. Washington Street, still wearing the same clothes and showing fire-related injuries on his right hand.

Gil Soffer told ABC 7 that the terrorism charge is “almost certainly the heaviest charge the government could have brought,” but “it’s not a reach.”

He explained that prosecutors simply have to show Reed intended to cause serious harm or death and did so on a “vehicle of mass transit.”

It’s a rare case where the law, the video, and the facts as described by officials all line up to justify a massive federal response.

Courtroom Outbursts And Mental Health Questions

When Reed made his initial appearance in federal court, Jermont Terry reports that he walked in handcuffed and wearing a spit guard over his mouth.

The hearing quickly became chaotic.

Terry says Reed repeatedly shouted, “I am guilty, and I will be my own attorney!”

He also yelled, “Don’t talk to me!” and even shouted “La, la, la” to drown out the judge, insisting he didn’t want a lawyer.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Laura K. McNally refused to accept any plea because the hearing was only meant to address the charges and detention.

She ordered Reed to undergo physical and mental evaluations ahead of his next hearing.

ABC 7’s Michelle Gallardo adds that Reed’s behavior, combined with his history, has raised questions about his competence and whether that could make it harder to secure a conviction.

U.S. Attorney Boutros told reporters he is “not aware of him ever being declared mentally incompetent” in connection with his previous record.

Gallardo also notes that ABC 7 Chicago legal analyst Gil Soffer pointed out how high the bar is to declare someone mentally unfit.

Soffer said the question isn’t whether Reed has mental health issues, but whether he had enough mental capacity to understand and carry out what he’s accused of doing.

In his view, the terrorism statute is straightforward: if Reed had the capacity to act and intended harm on a transit system, prosecutors can prove their case.

This is where the justice system is walking a tightrope: recognizing mental illness without letting truly dangerous people keep slipping back onto the street.

A Long Criminal History And A System Under Fire

While CBS Chicago counted 49 arrests going back years, Gallardo’s ABC 7 report focuses on at least 14 criminal cases in Cook County since 2017, including six battery charges.

Her reporting also notes that records suggest Reed may be homeless and dealing with mental illness.

Gallardo highlights several key moments that now stand out in hindsight.

In 2020, Reed was sentenced to 24 months of mental health probation after setting a fire outside the Thompson Center on a day Gov. J.B. Pritzker was expected to appear.

Earlier this year, in August, he was placed on electronic monitoring after he allegedly struck a social worker while being held at MacNeal Psychiatry Hospital in Berwyn.

CBS Chicago reports that Cook County prosecutors asked a judge to keep him detained in that August case because of the severity of the attack and his history.

Instead, a judge ordered electronic monitoring, and another judge later loosened his monitoring restrictions.

The Blue Line attack happened while Reed was supposed to be actively monitored.

ATF Special Agent in Charge Chris Amon has been blunt about what this all means.

Speaking at the news conference covered by both CBS Chicago and ABC 7, Amon said, “Lawrence Reed had no business being on the streets given his violent criminal history and pending criminal cases.”

He added that Reed had “plenty of second chances by the criminal justice system,” and now “we have an innocent victim in the hospital fighting for her life.”

That’s the heart of the outrage here: not just what happened on the train, but that it was carried out by someone who had already tripped every warning alarm the system had.

Punishment, Treatment, And Dangerous Gaps

ABC 7’s Michelle Gallardo spoke with Dr. David Olson, a criminology professor at Loyola University, to better understand why someone like Reed might be released instead of held.

Dr. Olson said it’s not always “punishment” that changes behavior, and judges may decide that treatment programs are more beneficial than incarceration in some cases.

He suggested the decision to release Reed on monitoring could have been based on the belief that continuing his treatment would be better than keeping him in jail.

From a policy standpoint, that reflects a broader shift toward mental health and rehabilitation.

But this case shows what happens when that shift isn’t paired with strong safeguards for public safety.

CBS legal analyst Irv Miller also weighed in, telling CBS Chicago that under Illinois’ SAFE-T Act, there is now a presumption of release instead of cash bail.

He stressed that this presumption “can be overcome easily” with a defendant like Reed, implying judges had all the legal tools they needed to keep him locked up.

Put bluntly, the experts quoted by Gallardo, Terry, and Machi are all circling the same problem:

The laws allowed Reed to be detained.

The system chose not to.

Terrorism Charge Raises The Stakes As City Waits

Both CBS Chicago and ABC 7 report that the terrorism charge Reed faces carries the possibility of life in prison.

Gil Soffer told ABC 7 that as long as Reed had the mental capacity to do what he’s accused of doing, the government can likely prove the elements of the crime.

He called it “almost certainly the heaviest charge” prosecutors could bring — and said it’s not a stretch in this case.

Reed is expected back in federal court for a detention hearing, where a judge will decide if he stays behind bars while the case moves forward.

Judge McNally has already ordered mental and physical evaluations, which will factor into what comes next.

Meanwhile, Gallardo reports that the victim’s family has issued a statement as she remains hospitalized, though details of that statement were not included in the coverage.

It’s a reminder that behind the legal debates and press conferences is a real family whose loved one may never fully recover.

Chicago officials, including Mayor Brandon Johnson, have promised more investment in transit safety, with Johnson saying “safety is our top priority” for CTA riders.

But for many people, especially those who ride the Blue Line every day, that promise now feels painfully late.

The combined reporting of Jermont Terry, Sara Machi, and Michelle Gallardo shows a case that’s about more than one horrific crime.

It’s about what happens when someone with a long, violent record, mental health problems, and multiple prior fires keeps getting another chance.

And it’s about a city asking, with good reason:

If this didn’t get him off the streets sooner, what would?

UP NEXT: “Heavily Armed” — See Which States Are The Most Strapped

Americans have long debated the role of firearms, but one thing is sure — some states are far more armed than others.

See where your state ranks in this new report on firearm ownership across the U.S.

The article ‘Why was he out on the streets?’: Man accused of setting woman on fire on train has long criminal history first appeared on Survival World.