Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

News

They were cast netting grassy flats — then officers found 81 mullet over the limit

They were cast netting grassy flats — then officers found 81 mullet over the limit
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

Three anglers who had been cast netting for mullet on grassy flats in Florida ended up facing criminal citations after wildlife officers counted their catch and determined the group was 81 fish over the recreational bag limit.

The April 23, 2024, encounter was shown in bodycam footage featured by the YouTube channel Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife, whose host said a plainclothes marine patrol officer first noticed the group fishing around Grassy Point near Anna Maria Island before meeting up with another Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission officer.

The officers watched as two of the men threw cast nets while a third pushed a large white cooler through the water, and they waited until the group began moving the catch toward a vehicle before making contact.

Officers Ask To See Everything In The Cooler

The encounter began calmly, with an FWC officer identifying himself and asking the men what they had caught.

“Mullet,” one of them answered.

The officer asked whether they had anything besides mullet and then requested that the fish be transferred by hand into another cooler so the officers could inspect the catch and make sure no other regulated species were mixed in.

Officers Ask To See Everything In The Cooler
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

The cooler was clearly heavy, and as the men began moving fish one by one, the size of the catch became more obvious.

The officer also asked whether everyone had a fishing license and started collecting identification while the count continued.

According to the Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife host, Florida’s recreational mullet rules vary depending on whether people are fishing from shore or from a vessel, and the officers treated this group as shore-based anglers.

Under the rule explained in the video, each angler could possess up to 50 mullet, giving the three men a combined limit of 150.

The Count Hits 150 — And Keeps Going

As the fish were transferred, one officer began counting aloud.

The number climbed through 60, then past 75, and the officers quickly realized the group was probably going to be over.

At 150, the officer stopped briefly and noted that they had already reached the legal combined limit.

There were still fish left.

The Count Hits 150 — And Keeps Going
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

By the time the count was completed, the officers said the group had 231 mullet, placing them 81 fish above the allowable total.

One of the men appeared confused about the rule and asked whether the limit was 100 fish per person.

The officer corrected him, explaining that it was 50 per person where they were fishing.

That exchange appears to have been genuine confusion rather than an argument, and the officers spent considerable time explaining that fishing regulations can differ by species, location and time of year.

Officers Decide Against More Serious Commercial Charges

Once the count was confirmed, the officers told all three men they would receive citations for possessing more than the recreational bag limit.

The FWC officer also explained that there were potentially more serious ways the case could have been handled because the quantity of fish pushed the matter toward rules separating recreational and commercial harvest.

He told them the commercial-related violations could carry more serious consequences, but said the officers were choosing to cite them only for the recreational bag-limit offense.

“We’re just going to write the recreational bag limit,” the officer said, making clear that he viewed that as a break.

The men were allowed to keep the other legal fish in their possession, including catfish and sheepshead that officers said were not a problem.

The interaction remained cooperative throughout, despite some language difficulties and confusion over where the men lived and what identification they had available.

Anglers Say They Thought The Rules Were Different

While officers completed the paperwork, one of the men suggested he had previously understood that the mullet limit could be 100 fish.

The officer replied that regulations can indeed vary in different places but said the 50-fish-per-person limit had applied in that area for a long time.

Anglers Say They Thought The Rules Were Different
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

He encouraged the men to check the state fishing regulation book in the future because even the same species may be governed differently depending on location or season.

That is probably the most useful lesson from the encounter.

Fishing rules can be surprisingly specific, and relying on what was legal somewhere else—or what someone remembers hearing years earlier—can become expensive very quickly when officers start counting fish.

The three men were each issued a notice to appear in Manatee County court.

The officer explained that signing the citation was not an admission of guilt but simply an acknowledgment that they had to appear before a judge because the violation was being treated as a criminal matter.

Court Records Show Different Outcomes For The Three Men

Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife later reviewed the court results for all three anglers.

According to the channel, one man pleaded guilty and had adjudication withheld.

He was ordered to pay $399.25 in fines and court costs, paid $300 immediately and was given six months to cover the remaining balance.

The host said he did not pay the remainder by the deadline, leading to a driver’s license suspension and the unpaid amount being sent to collections.

At the time the video was made, the channel said he still owed $131.25.

A second man pleaded no contest and also had adjudication withheld.

He received the same $399.25 total, paid $200 that day and was also given six months to pay what remained.

According to the host, he likewise failed to finish paying the balance, resulting in a suspended driver’s license and collection action, with $231.25 still due when the video was recorded.

The third man also pleaded no contest, but unlike the other two, he was adjudicated guilty.

He was ordered to pay $535 in fines and costs and did not make an initial payment, the channel reported.

After six months passed without payment, his driver’s license was also suspended and the balance was sent to collections.

Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife said his outstanding balance had grown to $567.50 by the time of the video.

A Fishing Violation Turned Into A Much Longer Problem

A Fishing Violation Turned Into A Much Longer Problem
Image Credit: Arrest Cam Fish and Wildlife

The channel calculated that the three cases still carried roughly $930 in unpaid balances combined when the follow-up was recorded, and all three men had experienced driver’s license suspensions after failing to satisfy their financial obligations.

What began as a day of cast netting on the flats therefore became much more expensive than the original fishing citations.

The officers had already chosen not to pursue the more serious commercial-related violations they discussed at the scene, yet the case still followed the men long after the fish were counted.

The bodycam footage also shows why wildlife officers often spend so much time physically counting and documenting a catch rather than relying on estimates.

At first glance, the cooler simply looked full.

Only after the fish were transferred one by one did it become clear that the group was not slightly over the limit, but 81 mullet beyond what the officers said the three anglers were legally allowed to possess.

For recreational anglers, the practical takeaway is straightforward: knowing the rules before the net goes in the water is much easier than trying to explain them after an officer starts counting the catch.

You May Also Like

News

Image Credit: Max Velocity - Severe Weather Center