Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

News

“The Bubble Has Burst”: Airbnb Hosts Are Now Being Shut Down

The Bubble Has Burst Airbnb Hosts Are Now Being Shut Down
Image Credit: Michael Bordenaro

The short-term rental boom that encouraged thousands of investors to buy properties and turn them into Airbnbs is facing new challenges, with tighter local regulations cutting into earnings and forcing some hosts to reconsider their business models.

Real estate expert and YouTuber Michael Bordenaro warned that many investors purchased homes when short-term rental income was unusually strong, assuming the money would continue flowing for years. Now, some are discovering that changing regulations, lower occupancy and rising ownership costs can quickly undermine those expectations.

In his latest video, Bordenaro examined the troubles facing Airbnb operators in New York City before turning to another financial concern: homeowners with adjustable-rate mortgages who could soon face sharply higher monthly payments.

New York City Crackdown Changes Airbnb Business

Bordenaro began by discussing New York City’s restrictions on short-term rentals, which he said had reduced listings across the five boroughs by approximately 90%.

He explained that the crackdown has made it difficult for property owners to operate the type of Airbnb business that became popular during the housing boom.

One significant restriction requires many hosts offering short stays to remain in the property with their guests.

That creates a problem for investors who purchased multiple homes expecting to operate them as independent vacation rentals.

New York City Crackdown Changes Airbnb Business
Image Credit: Survival World

According to Bordenaro, the changes have not necessarily benefited the remaining hosts by eliminating competition.

He described a Queens homeowner whose annual Airbnb revenue reportedly fell from approximately $30,000 to $11,000.

That represents a decline of more than 60%, before accounting for maintenance, utilities, insurance and other operating expenses.

Bordenaro emphasized that the difference between revenue and profit is especially important when evaluating rental investments.

A property bringing in $11,000 annually might generate little actual income once its ongoing costs are paid.

He also argued that complaints about parties, disruptive guests and unfamiliar visitors moving through residential neighborhoods have contributed to growing opposition to short-term rentals.

While those concerns are understandable, tighter rules can also affect homeowners who use occasional rentals to help cover their housing expenses rather than operating large investment businesses.

Hosts Face Lower Income and Less Privacy

Bordenaro highlighted one New York homeowner whose rental arrangement changed after inspectors identified violations involving a door separating his living area from guest accommodations.

The homeowner reportedly had to remove the door, leaving guests and residents sharing more of the same interior space.

That arrangement became particularly frustrating when visitors brought two large German shepherds that moved between floors and barked when someone approached the entrance.

Bordenaro questioned whether the remaining rental income justified the disruption to the owner’s daily life.

Hosts Face Lower Income and Less Privacy
Image Credit: Michael Bordenaro

Other hosts have attempted to avoid short-term rental restrictions by offering stays lasting 30 days or longer.

However, that approach has created different financial difficulties.

One Harlem property owner who previously rented an upper apartment for several days at a time reportedly switched to monthly stays, only to see her income decline substantially.

Bordenaro said her occupancy fell to approximately 60%, with rental revenue dropping by about half.

He explained that longer reservations can leave awkward gaps between tenants that owners can no longer fill with short visits.

For example, a guest might leave in the middle of September while the next renter cannot arrive until October, leaving the apartment vacant for weeks.

Meanwhile, the mortgage, property taxes and utility bills continue regardless of whether anyone is paying rent.

Another Brooklyn couple reportedly spent $30,000 renovating and furnishing an apartment primarily used by visiting relatives from India.

They previously earned around $25,000 annually by renting it during periods when family members were away, but their bookings declined after the new restrictions.

Bordenaro said the couple also faced increasing maintenance, insurance and utility expenses without being able to raise rental rates enough to offset them.

Investors Warned Against Depending on Airbnb Revenue

The experiences reinforced a warning Bordenaro said he had been giving investors for several years.

Anyone purchasing a property specifically for short-term rentals should consider whether the investment would remain financially viable as a traditional long-term rental.

If its profitability depends entirely on high nightly rates and frequent bookings, changes in local regulations can create serious financial pressure.

Bordenaro acknowledged that some Airbnb operators continue to perform well.

He mentioned a friend in Miami who manages more than 100 rental units nationwide and has remained successful by carefully managing risk and avoiding excessive dependence on individual properties.

The problem, he argued, is not that every short-term rental business is doomed, but that some investors assumed unusually favorable conditions would last indefinitely.

He also cited figures showing that New York City had approximately 3,500 registered short-term rental hosts as of June 2026, alongside roughly 9,000 operators offering stays of 30 days or longer.

For investors who paid high prices during the housing boom, the loss of expected rental income can make an already expensive property increasingly difficult to maintain.

That is particularly concerning when an investment is financed through debt that may become more expensive over time.

Adjustable-Rate Mortgages Could Deliver Another Shock

Bordenaro connected the problems facing rental owners with the risks of adjustable-rate mortgages, commonly known as ARMs.

He cited data from ICE Mortgage indicating that approximately 150,000 homeowners could experience their first mortgage rate adjustment during 2026.

Another 186,000 borrowers were expected to face their first adjustments in 2027.

Adjustable Rate Mortgages Could Deliver Another Shock
Image Credit: Survival World

Many of those homeowners obtained mortgages when interest rates were much lower, leaving them vulnerable to higher payments when their initial fixed-rate periods expire.

For example, Bordenaro described borrowers with seven-year adjustable-rate mortgages originating in 2019.

According to the figures he cited, a typical borrower in that group had an initial interest rate near 3% and an outstanding mortgage balance of approximately $548,000.

If the rate reset to around 6%, the monthly payment could increase by roughly $1,100.

That would create considerable pressure for households already struggling with rising living expenses.

Bordenaro warned against assuming that refinancing will always provide an escape.

Homeowners must still qualify for a new loan, and changes in income, creditworthiness or property values can make approval difficult.

However, he acknowledged that not every adjustable-rate borrower will experience a substantial increase, since some mortgages originated at higher rates and could reset more favorably.

His concern was that buyers may underestimate the possibility of higher payments when choosing a loan primarily because its initial rate is lower.

Michael Burry’s Advice Meets an Expensive Housing Market

The discussion then turned to investor Michael Burry, known for anticipating the financial problems that contributed to the 2008 housing crisis.

Bordenaro highlighted Burry’s advice that young buyers should consider purchasing a home costing substantially less than the maximum amount they can afford.

He described the suggestion as buying roughly half the house a person’s finances could support.

Although Bordenaro appreciated the emphasis on financial caution, he questioned whether it was realistic for many first-time buyers.

He cited Redfin figures suggesting that a household needed approximately $110,000 in annual income to afford the median-priced American home.

By comparison, he said median household income was slightly above $87,000.

That gap leaves many potential buyers unable to afford a typical property, making the idea of purchasing one at half their maximum budget even more difficult.

Bordenaro also referenced declining sales of newly built homes, reporting that September sales had slipped 0.6% from the previous month and 5.3% from a year earlier.

He argued that affordability remained a problem even as builders offered incentives and some new homes became comparatively less expensive than existing properties.

The broader issue is that buying below one’s financial limit requires affordable alternatives to exist in the first place.

In expensive housing markets, those alternatives may be scarce, particularly for younger households with limited savings.

Renting and Investing Could Offer Another Path

Renting and Investing Could Offer Another Path
Image Credit: Survival World

Bordenaro concluded by questioning the traditional belief that purchasing a home as early as possible is always the best way to build long-term wealth.

He argued that homeownership can consume a substantial share of household income once mortgage payments, insurance, taxes and maintenance are included.

For someone spending 45% to 50% of their income on housing, unexpected repairs or a job loss could quickly become financially difficult.

By comparison, he suggested that someone spending around 30% of their income on rent might have more money available for savings and investments.

Bordenaro recommended that younger people who cannot comfortably afford a home consider continuing to rent while investing regularly.

He pointed to the stock market’s strong long-term performance and emphasized the importance of maintaining accessible savings rather than tying every dollar to home equity or retirement accounts.

However, renting and investing is not automatically the better financial choice for every household.

Results depend on local rents, home prices, investment returns, taxes and whether someone consistently invests the money they save by renting.

Stock market investments can also lose value, particularly over shorter periods, while homeownership offers stability and benefits that are not captured by investment returns alone.

Still, Bordenaro’s larger point was that buyers should not feel compelled to purchase property simply because earlier generations viewed homeownership as an essential financial milestone.

The same caution applies to Airbnb investors, especially those relying on rental income to support large mortgage payments.

As regulations and financing costs change, the ability to handle lower revenue or higher expenses may matter more than the income a property generated during the strongest years of the rental boom.

You May Also Like

News

Image Credit: Max Velocity - Severe Weather Center