What started as a stunt by a small Idaho bar has now turned into a national argument about immigration, ethics, and even government judgment.
In Eagle, Idaho, the Old State Saloon posted on X that anyone who helps Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) “identify and ultimately deport an illegal from Idaho” would get “FREE BEER FOR ONE MONTH.”
The offer, first detailed by New York Post reporter Michael Sinkewicz, even promised that the bar “may award multiple months to one person if multiple illegals are deported.”
People who wanted to claim their free drinks were told to send photos, videos, or other evidence to a special email address, deportations@oldstatesaloon.com
, according to Sinkewicz’s reporting.
On its own, that post probably would have stayed a small, local flashpoint.
Then the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) stepped in.
DHS Repost Turns Local Promotion Into National Flashpoint
As Idaho News 6 reporter Don Nelson explains, the bar’s Nov. 29 post caught much more attention when DHS’s verified account reposted it, adding a GIF that showed apparent approval or surprise.
Nelson notes that DHS has official social media guidelines warning that the department should avoid doing anything online that creates the appearance of endorsing non-governmental statements or positions.
So when DHS boosted a private bar’s free-beer-for-deportations promo, it immediately raised questions.
Was this just a lighthearted repost?
Or was a federal agency signaling support for a business that was literally offering alcohol as a reward for turning in undocumented immigrants?
Nelson reports that Idaho News 6 reached out to both DHS and ICE for clarification and comment, but as of his story’s publication, there was no response.
That silence has only made the debate louder.
A government agency doesn’t have to say anything outright when a single repost sends its own message.
Inside The Bar Owner’s Pitch
Old State Saloon owner Mark Fitzpatrick has been anything but quiet about why he launched the promotion.
In a Fox News interview, Fitzpatrick told the network that his saloon is “not a stranger to speaking out boldly about conservative Christian values and truth.”

He framed the beer offer as a response to what he calls a “complete disaster” on the border under the Biden administration, claiming open borders have “incentivized some of the worst of the worst people in the world to come into this country.”
Fitzpatrick told Fox News he wanted to “encourage people to support law enforcement” and ICE, and said if someone provided information that led ICE to deport “an illegal from Idaho,” they would get free beer for a month.
Speaking to Don Nelson at Idaho News 6, Fitzpatrick tried to draw a line between what he’s offering and vigilante action.
“This is not about taking action or using force,” he told Nelson. “We’re just giving information to the authorities, to the law enforcement who’s enforcing the laws of the land.”
He also told Nelson he sees the promotion as honoring “community heroes,” pointing to Ryan Spoon, a local GOP official the bar publicly named as its first “hero” after claiming his tip helped remove a “dangerous illegal.”
Spoon, quoted by Nelson, said he doesn’t see a problem with the idea, arguing that undocumented immigrants “by definition” became criminals the moment they set foot on U.S. soil without authorization.
There’s a clear pattern in how Fitzpatrick frames it: law-abiding patriots on one side, lawbreakers on the other, and his saloon handing out what he presents as harmless rewards.
But once you put booze, immigration status, and public “heroes” in the same sentence, it stops feeling harmless very quickly.
Supporters Cheer – And Critics Warn Of Harm
Sinkewicz reports that the bar’s post drew loud applause from some conservative circles.
The Old State Saloon responded “Let’s go! Deport them all!” after DHS reposted the offer, according to his article.
Conservative Gen Z influencer Bo Loudon called the idea “incredible” on X and said, “This is why I love the United States,” Sinkewicz notes.
Sinkewicz also reports that one user even suggested a “Deporter of the Year” leaderboard with extra free beer as a grand prize.
On social media, the saloon leaned into the attention, posting about “1 star reviews rolling in from the loser LEFT,” and describing itself as the “Birthplace of Heterosexual Awesomeness Month,” a reference to a 2024 promotion where Fitzpatrick offered discounts and free beer to heterosexual men, women, and couples as a counter to Pride Month.
That earlier “Heterosexual Awesomeness Month” effort is something Fitzpatrick again brought up on Fox News, saying he’s used to being called homophobic, fascist, or worse, and that criticism only makes him “double down.”
He told Fox News he’s now getting violent threats, including people online saying his bar should be burned down and even threats aimed at his family.
He described messages that say he and his loved ones should die or be harmed, calling them “really, really despicable.”
Whatever people think of his promotion, those kinds of threats are beyond the line and only feed more anger into an already heated situation.
At the same time, it’s hard to ignore how the saloon’s own rhetoric is designed to provoke — not just invite discussion, but pick a fight.
Legal Grey Area, Ethical Red Flags
From a legal standpoint, Idaho News 6 dug into whether Old State Saloon might be breaking alcohol rules.
Captain Rocky Gripton of the Idaho State Police Alcohol Beverage Control Division told Nelson that offering free beer like this is “an event outside the normal course of business” and seems “counter intuitive, but not illegal.”

In other words, the state doesn’t like the look of it, but it doesn’t clearly violate Idaho’s Title 23 alcohol laws.
On the immigration side, Nelson notes that ICE already has a formal public tip system, with procedures for reviewing information and deciding what, if anything, to act on.
This is where immigration attorney J.J. Despain steps in.
Despain told Nelson that promotions like this are “a slippery slope,” warning that while ICE is tasked with enforcing immigration laws, it’s risky to encourage “random people doing their job for them.”
He pointed out that involving untrained members of the public could create dangerous situations, including misidentifications, false accusations, or confrontations that escalate.
You don’t need much imagination to see how that could go wrong — especially in a climate where immigration is already a lightning-rod issue and people may rely on stereotypes or grudges rather than solid information.
And although Fitzpatrick insists this is all about “awareness” and “discussion,” putting a month of free beer on the table changes the tone: it turns immigration enforcement into a kind of contest, with prizes for participation.
That might be good marketing.
But it’s a poor way to approach people’s legal status and safety.
Community Concerns And Human Rights Warnings
Beyond the legal questions, the bar’s offer is also stirring deeper concerns about what it does to local trust.
Nelson reports that the Wassmuth Center for Human Rights in Boise released a statement condemning the promotion.
The center said, “Incentivizing Idahoans to turn in their neighbors to get some free beer further dehumanizes people and divides our communities.”
Instead of turning people against one another, the center argued, Idaho should be working “to build communities where human rights are a lived reality for all.”
That criticism gets at something Fitzpatrick and his supporters don’t really address.
When you invite customers to report “illegals” in exchange for alcohol and public praise, you’re not just helping ICE do its job.
You’re also sending a clear message to anyone who looks or sounds “foreign” that they might be watched, judged, and turned in by the guy in the next barstool.
Nelson’s story notes that even DHS’s own social media rules urge caution about engaging with private content in ways that could look like official endorsement.
The fact that DHS hasn’t explained its repost only adds to the sense that lines are being blurred – between law enforcement and ideology, between policy and online clout.
A Small Bar, A Big Symbol

Taken together, the reporting from Fox News, Michael Sinkewicz at the New York Post, and Don Nelson at Idaho News 6 shows how one small business can become a symbol in a much larger national fight.
Fitzpatrick sees himself as a blunt-spoken Christian conservative standing up to what he calls “evil” and “deception,” using his bar as a gathering place for like-minded people and for debate.
Supporters cheer him as someone willing to “stick his neck out” when others stay silent.
But critics see something more troubling: a private business gamifying deportation, turning tips about undocumented neighbors into a rewards program branded with slogans like “Deport them all.”
In a time when immigration policy is already charged, and when federal deportations and raids are sparking fear in communities across the country, it’s hard not to be uneasy about a bar owner tying free alcohol to people’s immigration status.
Even if the promotion technically fits inside Idaho’s alcohol rules, and even if some tips really do go through proper ICE channels, the message it sends is far bigger than a month of free beer.
It tells some people they’re welcome to raise a glass – and tells others they might be one “hero” away from being reported by a stranger with a smartphone and a bar tab to win.

Mark grew up in the heart of Texas, where tornadoes and extreme weather were a part of life. His early experiences sparked a fascination with emergency preparedness and homesteading. A father of three, Mark is dedicated to teaching families how to be self-sufficient, with a focus on food storage, DIY projects, and energy independence. His writing empowers everyday people to take small steps toward greater self-reliance without feeling overwhelmed.


































