Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

News

America needs tradespeople. So why can’t they find jobs?

America needs tradespeople. So why can’t they find jobs
Image Credit: USA TODAY

Americans worried that artificial intelligence could reshape or eliminate parts of the white-collar job market are increasingly being told to consider the skilled trades, where electricians, plumbers, mechanics and HVAC technicians are expected to remain in demand for years.

But a closer look at the labor market reveals a more complicated picture.

On USA TODAY’s The Excerpt, host Dana Taylor spoke with Money reporter Rachel Barber about a puzzle she and national correspondent Jessica Guynn found while examining the trades: employers say they cannot find enough qualified workers, yet people who complete training or certification programs sometimes say they still cannot find jobs.

Barber said both things can be true because demand varies sharply by occupation and location, while employers are also reluctant to hire just anyone simply because they hold a certificate.

America Really Does Need More Skilled Workers

Taylor pointed to research from the Alliance for America’s Skilled Trades estimating that employers will need to fill roughly 1.7 million skilled-trade openings each year through 2035.

Barber said the consequences of failing to fill those jobs could eventually become visible in everyday life.

She cited Ford CEO Jim Farley, who told USA TODAY that shortages could first show up in relatively ordinary ways, such as longer waits at auto repair shops or infrastructure projects taking more time and costing more money.

America Really Does Need More Skilled Workers
Image Credit: USA TODAY

In more serious situations, however, the shortage could affect essential services.

Farley pointed to examples such as a water-treatment plant that needs a plumber or electrician, or an ambulance that requires repairs and cannot get them quickly enough.

That is where the labor shortage stops being a discussion about salaries and starts becoming a question about whether basic systems can keep running.

The broader warning is difficult to ignore because skilled trades are tied directly to the physical systems people rely on every day, from transportation and utilities to housing and emergency services.

Interest Is There, But The Pipeline Keeps Losing People

One surprising part of the research is that young people and their parents do not appear to reject trade careers as strongly as older stereotypes might suggest.

Taylor noted that most teenagers and parents surveyed said they would be proud of a career in the skilled trades.

Barber said the problem may be less about interest and more about what happens after that interest begins.

She pointed to school counselors as one part of the disconnect.

While 95% of counselors surveyed said trade school is valuable and credible, only 28% frequently recommend apprenticeship as a pathway.

Farley described the broader cultural bias in simple terms, telling Barber that “the air we breathe is a four-year degree.”

Interest Is There, But The Pipeline Keeps Losing People
Image Credit: USA TODAY

That pressure toward college still shapes how students think about success, even as tuition costs rise and entry-level white-collar hiring becomes less predictable.

The numbers get even more concerning once people actually enter training.

According to Barber, only 48 out of every 100 people who start an apprenticeship complete it, and just 29 enter a trade occupation within five years.

Postsecondary programs show a similar pattern, with 48 out of 100 completing and 34 eventually entering the trades.

That suggests the labor shortage cannot be solved simply by convincing more people to sign up for training.

The larger challenge is keeping them in the pipeline long enough to become experienced workers.

Demand Does Not Mean A Job Is Waiting Everywhere

Taylor returned to the contradiction at the center of the discussion: if employers need so many tradespeople, why are newly certified workers still struggling to get hired?

Barber said the answer starts with geography and specialization.

Mechanics, for example, are in particularly high demand, while workers in states such as Florida and Arizona may have a much easier time finding opportunities than those in places like West Virginia or Michigan, where demand pressure is lower.

That means a national labor shortage does not automatically translate into a shortage in every town or for every trade.

Someone can complete training in a field with strong national projections and still live in an area where employers are not hiring aggressively.

Employers also have reasons to be cautious.

Barber noted that training and equipping a new worker is expensive, so companies still want candidates who appear reliable, competent and able to handle the job.

A certification may get someone through the door, but it does not guarantee an offer.

That is probably the most important correction to the current hype around the trades.

The message that “America needs electricians” is broadly true, but it is not the same thing as saying every newly trained electrician will immediately find a high-paying job.

The Work Can Be Much Harder Than The Sales Pitch

Barber also told Taylor about 24-year-old Will Ryan, an MBA graduate who left the white-collar path and decided to become an electrician.

Ryan hoped the trade would give him more security in an economy increasingly shaped by AI, and he eventually wanted to open his own electrical contracting business.

He found work as an apprentice on a major data-center project, and the pay was decent.

The schedule, however, was brutal.

The Work Can Be Much Harder Than The Sales Pitch
Image Credit: USA TODAY

Barber said Ryan was working 10- to 12-hour shifts six days a week, leaving very little time for his marriage or for the business training he hoped to complete.

After about six months, he left and went back to looking for white-collar work.

His experience does not mean the trades are a bad option, but it does expose how easily they can be romanticized.

People often hear about experienced electricians or plumbers earning six figures, yet those incomes can take years of skill-building, networking and eventually self-employment to reach.

As Barber put it, there are no shortcuts to earning that kind of money.

The highest earnings often come after someone has built a reputation, a client base and enough expertise to work independently or run a business.

That is not very different from the slow climb that many white-collar workers make toward senior positions.

A Hybrid Path May Be Stronger Than Choosing One Side

Taylor asked whether the answer has to be college or the trades, or whether combining the two might create a stronger career path.

Barber said one of her sources suggested that a four-year degree paired with a technical credential in areas such as electricity, HVAC or water systems could be especially valuable in places with major data-center construction.

That combination could give workers both technical and broader business or management skills.

The obvious downside is cost.

Someone pursuing both paths may take on student debt and then still need additional time and money for certification.

For many families, that is not realistic.

Still, the idea challenges the simplistic debate that young people must choose between college and manual work.

In some industries, the strongest future worker may be someone who understands both.

AI May Reshape The Trades, But Not Immediately Replace Them

The interview also addressed one of the biggest reasons interest in trade careers has increased: the belief that these jobs are “AI-proof.”

Barber said that label is probably too strong.

AI May Reshape The Trades, But Not Immediately Replace Them
Image Credit: USA TODAY

For now, the AI boom is actually creating more demand for skilled workers because data centers need electricians, HVAC technicians and other specialists to build and maintain the physical infrastructure behind the technology.

But robotics and automation are likely to affect blue-collar jobs eventually, just on a different timeline.

Barber referenced Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, who has predicted that robots could begin competing with people for some physical jobs by the end of the decade.

Farley also told her that Ford is already experimenting with augmented-reality glasses to help technicians repair vehicles more efficiently, though he described the technology as a way to help workers rather than replace them.

The common thread is that human judgment still matters.

Whether someone is deciding how to repair a complex vehicle or making a financial decision in an office, Barber said experts continue to see value in workers who can interpret unusual situations rather than simply follow a predictable routine.

The Shortage Is Real, But So Are The Barriers

The skilled-trades story is not as simple as one side having jobs and the other having workers.

America does appear to need far more tradespeople over the coming decade, especially as older workers retire and infrastructure, manufacturing and data-center projects expand.

At the same time, training pipelines lose people, some regions have far more demand than others, employers remain selective and the work itself can be physically demanding enough to push people back toward other careers.

Taylor and Barber’s discussion makes clear that the trades are a legitimate option, but not a guaranteed escape hatch from white-collar uncertainty.

For some workers, they may offer strong pay, independence and long-term demand.

For others, the hours, physical strain, training period or local job market may make the path less attractive than it first appeared.

The contradiction disappears once those realities are considered together: America can have a serious shortage of experienced tradespeople while still making it difficult for new workers to become the experienced tradespeople employers actually want.

You May Also Like

News

Image Credit: Max Velocity - Severe Weather Center