Skip to Content

Horror on the Hillside: The True Story of Appalachia’s Killer Couple

Tucked deep within the rugged wilderness of Appalachia, a story of horror and heartbreak unfolded in 1927 that shook the region and captivated the nation. It began as a cold December morning in Greenup County, Kentucky, with two young boys sprinting through the frostbitten forest to seek the help of a mountain doctor. What they revealed would uncover a tragedy so sinister it left the tight-knit Appalachian community reeling.

A Frozen Morning and a Frantic Search for Help

A Frozen Morning and a Frantic Search for Help
Image Credit: Survival World

Tommy and John, two boys living in the remote hills, pounded on the door of the local mountain doctor’s cabin. Their urgency was palpable as they explained that their three-year-old sister, Mary Magdalene Pitts, was dead. They pleaded with the doctor to prepare her for a funeral. The old man, accustomed to delivering babies, treating injuries, and even dressing the dead in the isolated region, gathered his coat and followed the boys into the frigid wilderness.

A Shocking Scene

A Shocking Scene
Image Credit: Dead Internet Chronicles

Upon arriving at the Pitts family’s modest three-room cabin, the doctor was greeted by a crowd of neighbors. On the kitchen table lay the small, lifeless body of Mary Magdalene, her golden hair and pale features still. But beneath her white nightgown, the doctor uncovered something horrifying – bruises, scars, and fresh wounds covered her tiny frame. A deep, U-shaped head wound drew his attention. Though he said little at the time, the doctor left the home with a heavy heart and growing suspicions.

The Mountain Code Meets the Law

The Mountain Code Meets the Law
Image Credit: Survival World

In Appalachian communities, mountain folk were known for handling matters within their own circles, avoiding interference from outsiders, particularly law enforcement. However, the doctor’s suspicions led him to the unthinkable: he visited the county coroner, Lewis Compton, a man he had long distrusted. The doctor shared his belief that Mary Magdalene’s death wasn’t natural, citing evidence of potential poisoning. The coroner, along with local law enforcement, launched an investigation that would pierce the veil of mountain secrecy.

Uncovering a Nightmare

Uncovering a Nightmare
Image Credit: Find a Grave

When officers and a medical examiner arrived at the Pitts cabin, they were met with hostility from the gathered crowd. Inside, the housekeeper, Marie Frazier, answered their questions nervously, repeating that the child had always been sickly and thirsty. But the wounds told a different story. As the medical examiner inspected Mary’s body, he found extensive injuries, including burns and bruises. The chilling discovery deepened when neighbors and other children revealed the dark truth: Mary had suffered frequent beatings and abuse.

The Troubled Past of Robert Pitts

The Troubled Past of Robert Pitts
Image Credit: Find a Grave

As investigators delved into the life of Robert Pitts, Mary’s father, they uncovered a troubling history. Once a respected schoolteacher, Pitts had fallen into a life of hardship. He had lost his wife and taken in Marie Frazier as a housekeeper, though their relationship was far from professional – she was pregnant with his child. Pitts’ previous relationships and his treatment of Mary Magdalene painted a grim picture of a man whose darker tendencies had long gone unchecked.

The Community Turns

The Community Turns
Image Credit: Find a Grave

As word of Mary Magdalene’s death spread, so did outrage. Mountain folk, typically distrustful of outsiders, united in a call for justice. When the details of Mary’s abuse became public knowledge, thousands of people descended upon Greenup County, demanding accountability. The community’s anguish was captured in the funeral home where Mary’s battered body lay in state, cradling a stuffed animal in one hand and a Bible in the other. A sign above her read, “Won’t you see that I get justice?”

A Father’s Horrific Confession

A Father’s Horrific Confession
Image Credit: Find a Grave

Under the mounting pressure of the investigation, Robert Pitts finally confessed. He claimed Marie Frazier had inflicted much of the abuse, detailing how she had burned Mary over a cook stove and reopened her healing wounds with salt and turpentine. Pitts admitted witnessing the cruelty, but his own actions were no less reprehensible. He described how Mary had been hung upside down and beaten regularly. When she was near death, he contemplated her funeral rather than seeking help.

Marie Frazier’s Defense

Marie Frazier’s Defense
Image Credit: Find a Grave

Frazier, in turn, pointed the finger at Pitts, accusing him of wielding the iron poker that delivered the fatal blow to Mary’s head. She painted a picture of a controlling, violent man who had tortured his daughter to death in a twisted attempt to erase any ties to Mary’s mother. Frazier’s pleas of innocence fell flat under the weight of her own involvement in the ongoing abuse.

A Community’s Anguish

A Community’s Anguish
Image Credit: Find a Grave

By the time Mary Magdalene was laid to rest, her story had become national news. Over 10,000 mourners attended her funeral, traveling by riverboats and trains to pay their respects. The sight of her small coffin, carried by young girls and surrounded by flowers, was a haunting reminder of the cruelty she endured. For Appalachia, it was a moment of reckoning, as the community grappled with the horror that had occurred in their midst.

The Trial

The Trial
Image Credit: Find a Grave

When the trial began, it drew a massive crowd, with hundreds packing the courthouse and thousands more gathering outside. Both Pitts and Frazier pleaded not guilty, each blaming the other for Mary’s death. The prosecution revealed damning evidence, including notes Pitts had written that outlined plans for Mary’s funeral even before her death. The jury deliberated swiftly, convicting both Pitts and Frazier of first-degree murder and sentencing them to life in prison.

Justice Served

Justice Served
Image Credit: Find a Grave

The verdict brought a sense of closure to the grieving community, though the wounds left by Mary Magdalene’s death would linger for years. Her story remains one of the most harrowing tales to emerge from Appalachia, a stark reminder of the region’s struggles with isolation, poverty, and deeply ingrained social codes.

Remembering Mary Magdalene

Remembering Mary Magdalene
Image Credit: Dead internet Chronicles

Today, the story of Mary Magdalene Pitts reminds us about the dangers of unchecked power and the importance of seeking justice, no matter how tight-knit a community may be. Her short life, marked by unimaginable suffering, became a rallying cry for change, proving that even in the most remote corners of the world, the demand for accountability cannot be silenced. Mary’s memory endures, a tragic yet powerful reminder that justice, though often slow, can prevail.