McDonald’s Price Hikes Are Driving Away Budget Customers

McDonald’s is selling more per visit, but seeing fewer visits from the people who used to live on value menus.

On the PBD Podcast, host Patrick Bet-David read through the company’s latest snapshot: U.S. same-store sales up ~2.4%, overall comps up 3.6%, but earnings light as the chain warned that lower-income traffic fell nearly double digits in Q3 and has been weakening for almost two years. 

That’s the tell. The checks are bigger. The crowd is smaller. And the missing crowd is the price-sensitive base Bet-David’s team says has been squeezed by inflation.

Co-host Tom Ellsworth translated the corporate phrasing. Revenue is rising because prices rose, not because more budget diners are showing up. In his read, that’s “bifurcation” – people who can absorb inflation are still buying; lower-income families are cutting back.

The Vanishing Value Meal

Ellsworth pointed to a simple reality anyone can see on the menu boards: the #1–#8 combos cost more.

On air, Bet-David and the crew pulled up price examples to illustrate the sticker shock – what used to feel like a cheap burger now looks like a $6–$8 single and a double-digit combo in many markets. The exact price depends on location and promotion, but the perception is set.

And perception matters in fast food. If a “value” meal no longer feels like value, the whole proposition breaks.

Even PBD’s live viewer poll told the same story: roughly three-quarters said they’re dining out less than before. That isn’t a scientific sample, but it aligns with McDonald’s own warning about traffic softness among budget customers.

A Split Consumer, Loud and Clear

The “two Americas” theme carried over to Fox Business’s The Big Money Show.

Anchor Dagen McDowell opened bluntly: fast-food sales are flashing warning signs as Americans, “especially younger Americans,” pull back. Brands from Coca-Cola to Chipotle are signaling the same divide – some trade down, others don’t need to.

Investor Lou Basenese added a portfolio lens. Consumer staples and big restaurant names are sending mixed signals. 

Meanwhile, GLP-1 weight-loss drugs are a new headwind, potentially reducing appetite and frequency. Not the primary driver, but a drag that didn’t exist a few years ago.

Co-host Jackie DeAngelis drilled into perceived value erosion: prices up, portioning and inputs cheaper, and quality concerns rising as chains try to protect margins. If the experience feels worse while costing more, people start packing lunch.

That tracks with the PBD conversation too. Once habitual buyers feel burned, they retrain to alternatives.

Why Profits Still Lag

Here’s the paradox both shows highlighted in different ways.

McDonald’s can post higher average checks and positive comps, but still come up short on profits if traffic declines and costs stay elevated. 

Food, labor, utilities, and remodel investments have all risen. Temporary value bundles can buy traffic, but they compress margin unless vendors or franchisees absorb the hit.

Ellsworth argued there’s also an enforcement gap between what’s on the books and what customers experience day-to-day: in this context, a brand can promise value, but franchise-level pricing varies widely by market, leaving some guests feeling priced out despite corporate promotions.

From the markets side, McDowell noted consumer staples lagging while tech rallies – a classic risk-on rotation that doesn’t help defensive restaurant stocks. If the consumer slows, the laggards can lag more.

McDonald’s Tries a Fix – But Will It Work?

The chain isn’t just sitting still.

Co-host Taylor Riggs said McDonald’s tested a $5 meal deal that “resonated,” and is now piloting “crafted” sodas and refreshers in ~500 stores across Colorado and Wisconsin. The CEO reportedly said the drinks performed well in trials.

Riggs framed the strategy as a bid to fill off-peak dayparts and hook younger, health-leaning consumers who live on social beverages as much as burgers. If the price is right, cold drinks can be high-margin, traffic-friendly, and social-media-shareable.

Basenese was skeptical about the brand fit – “crafted” doesn’t scream McDonald’s. But there’s logic here: low-cost beverages can re-establish a value anchor and rebuild frequency without discounting the core sandwich too deeply. 

DeAngelis even noted she’s shifted coffee spend to the McDonald’s app from pricier spots – proof that micro-value can win if it’s simple and consistent.

The Politics and the Pocketbook

The PBD panel pushed harder on macro blame.

Ellsworth tied the two-year traffic slide to “Biden-inflation,” arguing that lower-income buyers are the first to opt out when groceries, gas, and rent jump. He suggested manufacturing and wage growth are the real antidotes, even as he conceded no administration fixes this in months.

Whether you agree or not, the apolitical data point remains: price-sensitive traffic is down, and it’s been down persistently. For a brand built on everyday affordability, that’s an existential warning, not a blip.

On Fox Business, McDowell described a “rolling recession” – some sectors hurt while others hold up. That would explain how McDonald’s can report resilient sales while entry-level guests quietly churn out.

What Budget Diners Are Doing Instead

Both conversations hinted at the same substitution pattern.

First, grocery over drive-thru, especially for breakfasts and lunches. DeAngelis pointed out that packing from home is now the cheapest alternative when fast food no longer offers real savings.

Second, à la carte over meals. Riggs mentioned the app and single-item buys as ways younger consumers hack value. That matters: unbundling can move the check down just enough to keep people in the habit without full combos.

Third, delivery deals and coupons. On PBD, the crew noted that delivery apps sometimes show better promos than in-store – odd, but it keeps occasional purchases alive.

The Brand Risk No One Can Ignore

Basenese flagged another danger: brand staleness.

When price hikes collide with weaker perceived quality, guests don’t just buy less – they re-rank the brand. That’s stickier and far more costly to fix.

If refreshers and value bundles feel like short-term gimmicks, they won’t repair the core promise. 

If, however, McDonald’s nails simple, reliable price points (think everyday $1–$2 coffee, clean app deals, honest portioning), it can rebuild trust where it’s been lost.

Consistency beats novelty in quick-service. Especially in a downturn.

From the PBD Podcast, the message is blunt: price hikes have thinned out lower-income traffic, and that’s been a two-year trend. Bigger checks don’t fully offset a missing base, and sentiment is sour among budget shoppers.

From Fox Business’s Big Money Show, the macro echoes: inflation fatigue, health-conscious shifts, GLP-1 effects, and a weaker staples complex all spell a cautious consumer. McDonald’s is experimenting, but the category backdrop is tough.

Here’s the practical read for the Golden Arches:

If “value” no longer means value, foot traffic will keep sliding at the low end. The fix isn’t to chase Starbucks with craft drinks or to run one-off flash discounts. It’s to re-anchor everyday affordability – clear price points, dependable quality, and frictionless app offers that feel like a win every time.

That’s how you get the budget crowd to come back weekly, not weakly. And right now, frequency – more than flashy comps – is the number that matters.

UP NEXT: “Heavily Armed” — See Which States Are The Most Strapped

Americans have long debated the role of firearms, but one thing is sure — some states are far more armed than others.

See where your state ranks in this new report on firearm ownership across the U.S.

The article McDonald’s Price Hikes Are Driving Away Budget Customers first appeared on Survival World.